On November 22nd 2008, the Peru Support Group held its annual conference and commemorated its 25th anniversary in London. PSG President Lord Avebury opened the 25-year anniversary annual conference and reflected on the quarter of a century of the organisation’s existence. He posed the question of whether the PSG is still relevant and if so, what contribution it has to make as a small NGO. It was hoped that this question would be answered by the end of the day.
Rosemary Thorp – Keynote Speaker
As a specialist on the development and economic history of Peru, Rosemary’s recent work has focused on inequality and conflict in Peru, including the implications of the recent boom in minerals for indigenous communities.
In her keynote discussion, Rosemary examined why mining is so conflictive in Peru, and why the rights of the communities affected are so difficult to address. As an economic activity, it is prone to conflict especially in developing countries because it occurs in a specific territorial locations and is extremely capital intensive. Consequently, this heightens people’s expectations particularly around employment, which when not met can lead to conflict.
Expectations are often high when new mining projects are proposed. A key question to consider and the challenge for mining companies is how to best manage these before a project comes into existence? The implementation of legitimate consultation processes around mining projects is problematic. For example, at the basic logistical level, how can mining companies ensure people are able to participate in consultations if these are held outside the proposed project area?
The case of the popular referendum in held in 2002 in Tambogrande (Piura) over a proposed mine has changed the face of mining negotiations in Peru and is symbolic of democratising people’s right to participate in state and company negotiations. Although the result of the referendum was non-binding, the local population voted overwhelmingly against mining activities by Canadian company Manhattan Minerals and the company subsequently withdrew from the area.
Protests over livelihoods take place in remote areas where there is no easy solution to provide people with viable alternatives. It is up to the state to guarantee this right and not the role or responsibility of multinational corporations. The benefits of mining can and should extend beyond the region where the activity takes place as it can be a useful tool for a country’s national development. The key question is how far should Peru’s development now be compromised against that of future generations?
Rosemary concluded by stating that a key success of the PSG’s 2007 report on the Río Blanco mining project was its critique of the role of the ministry of mining. This has lifted the level of debate and discussion on such issues and situations. However, there is also a backlash as individuals involved in the process have been publicly criticised and recent legislation has been introduced to shorten the time and provisions for consultation that would make public participation meaningful in discussions around potential mining projects.
Workshop: Uncontacted Indigenous Peoples in the Peruvian Amazon –
David Hill
David is a researcher and campaigner for NGO Survival International and has researched some of the world’s last remaining uncontacted tribes in the Peruvian Amazon. As a starting point, David addressed the question of: ‘Who are uncontacted tribes?’ Although conceptually difficult to define, he said that these are broadly taken to refer to indigenous peoples who have no contact with national society and where there is no state presence, tourists, missionaries, or corporations.
Survival International estimates there are 15 uncontacted tribes in Peru. All of them live in the most remote, isolated regions of the Amazon rainforest. However, the plight of these groups is not helped by the doubts raised about their existence by key figures in Peru. Even President García has suggested that the notion of uncontacted tribes is an invented term.
David highlighted some of the threats that these groups are facing, for example: the land rights of uncontacted tribes are not recognised; five reserves have been proposed for groups but not yet created and in any case the government is not able to stop people from entering these reserves and allows extractive industries, such as gas and oil companies Camisea and PetroBras, to work there.
Survival International’s position is that uncontacted tribes should be able to pursue their livelihoods free from interference as they wish. The organisation believes that the state can play a role by upholding the international mechanisms in place to respect rights of indigenous peoples. It also believes that the state should outlaw exploration projects on uncontacted tribal land and secure reserves from illegal logging and oil exploration activities (www.survival-international.org).
(2) Transfer from State to local and regional governments of a percentage of tax revenue generated by the mining sector.
Workshop: Integrated Water Management and Gender in a Changing Climate. Reflections from the Ground – María Arce
María currently works as a policy adviser for UK NGO Practical Action. She covers a range of issues including climate change, finance, energy, governance and environmental sustainability. In her presentation, she spoke about integrated water resources management and gender in a changing climate, and gave some specific examples from Practical Action’s projects in Peru
María flagged up the potential for increased conflict over water resources in Peru. She said that such potential was exacerbated by many factors such as: demands by big companies; and the imposition of a water management model by the state which promotes exclusion and views water as a simple commodity, without taking into account the Andean view which promotes principles of use, sharing and the kind of management that favours equity, efficiency and minimises social conflict.
She also drew links between climate change and an emerging pattern of gender challenges. For example, climate change will require women and men to adapt their water usage as there will be increased pressure on water resources which could lead to tensions between domestic and agricultural water needs (www.practicalaction.org).
Workshop: Indigenous People, Petroleum, and the Amazon Rainforest
Gregor MacLennan
Gregor is founder and director of Shinai, a small Peruvian NGO that supports indigenous people in the Peruvian Amazon to defend their rights and choose their own future. He spoke about the official indigenous territories and the threat of oil exploration, particularly the danger of oil spills, in the Peruvian Amazon.
He focused on the Achuar indigenous communities in the northern Amazon and explained their struggle and ultimate victory with the Argentine oil company Pluspetrol. In 2007, Pluspetrol agreed to forego drilling 39 proposed new wells on Achuar land.
Gregor also described some of the work that he did with different groups, including: training them with GPS equipment and working to create a detailed map of their territories – including hunting, fishing and meaningful areas. He also helped members of the tribes to take photographic and video evidence of oil spills, to prove their existence and also because this gave the oil companies more incentive to clean them up quicker. He explained how techniques used to clean up oil spills often lead to toxins infiltrating the local food chain.
In conclusion, Gregor made the point that many of the tribes he worked with have access to plentiful natural resources and so are not living in poverty; and that the indigenous peoples should be helped to maintain their ways of living as a means to preventing further poverty (www.shinai.org.pe).
Workshop: Poverty and Children’s Rights in Peru: Past; Present; and Future
Luz Barreto
Luz works for Peruvian NGO Centro Proceso Social. She addressed the issue of child poverty from a rights perspective. She proposed that an emphasis should be put on quality basic education for all children from six to 11 years of age (as outlined in the National Action Plan for children and adolescents 2002-2010). She also advocated for the creation of spaces to give children and adolescents a greater voice.
Luz highlighted certain characteristics that identify the most excluded children in Peru: they generally live in the country’s inland regions (mountains and jungle); they are largely from rural areas; they are often indigenous and speak indigenous languages; and on the whole the most excluded children are female.
Peru has ratified the UN’s 1990 Convention on the Rights of the Child; in 1992 it passed the Code for Children and Adolescents which modernised the former Code for Minors; the state has drawn up a long term Action Plan for Children (2002-2010); it has ratified both of the ILO Child Labour Conventions (138 and 182); and, as of 2005, children are now an integral part of the country’s goals to reduce poverty. However, she concluded that this isn’t enough.
What policy needs is a greater budget, particularly in education. Children need to be positioned directly in the state’s priorities and local, regional and national plans for children need to be fulfilled. Finally, Luz encouraged greater commitment from sectors of civil society and the promotion of the direct participation of children as decision makers with a role to play in their own destiny.
Conference Conclusions
In the final plenary session, and with the benefit of information gleaned from the day’s various workshops, participants and audience members highlighted the importance of using international mechanisms to further the PSG’s future work. For example, what useful mechanisms exist at the UN or EU level?
Lord Avebury advocated collaborating with other UK NGOs looking at the rights of indigenous peoples. He summed up the event by saying that the workshops and subsequent discussions are proof that there is still a lot of work for the PSG to do. But the organisation’s focus on publishing and disseminating information should not only be with a view to increasing the PSG’s membership, but equally as a means to reach out to a wider public.
Recent Comments