The battle over the Yanacocha mining company’s proposed opencast mine, known as Conga, has been non-stop since 2011. The company (51% owned by Newmont, 43% by the Peruvian-owned Buenaventura, and 5% by the International Finance Corporation, IFC) was forced by the government to suspend plans in 2012, after violent clashes that led to five deaths. At the heart of the conflict is water use, pollution and land ownership.

Two important events have occurred this month. In the first week of August a provincial judge found against the family of Maxima Chaupe, ordering them to hand over their 75-acre farm to the company. He also imposed a fine and suspended gaol sentences. The family will appeal, says Mirtha Vásquez, executive secretary of GRUFIDES, the NGO working with civil society groups to protect their rights. This is but the most recent development in a long battle between the family and the company (see PSG News Briefing, 16 December 2013).

Secondly, last week, Vásquez was able to announce, amid much expectation, that the hearing by the Constitutional Tribunal would be held on 27 September at 9.30 am in Lima. This is the long-awaited response to the acción de amparo (a legal remedy to protect individual constitutional rights) brought in 2012 by civil society representatives. It was claimed that the project would cause “irreversible damage” and invade citizens’ constitutional right to live in an appropriate and balanced environment. Specifically, the writ seeks to get the resolution approving the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) presented by the company declared invalid on constitutional grounds, and with it to secure the cancellation of the project.

Since then, the company has submitted two modifications to the EIA (which comprises 1,427 pages, excluding maps and annexes). Vásquez says these modifications have left citizens unclear and insecure about the changes this will involve and the effect these may have.

The hearing takes place in the context of a significant general weakening of environmental controls applicable to extractive projects (see last month’s Update).