Tuesday 5 May saw the tragic death of Henry Checcla, 35, in a clash with police that had begun on Monday night in the Tambo Valley in Arequipa. Many, both police and protesters, have been injured in a sequence of bitter conflicts in the valley over Southern Peru Copper’s plans to develop the Tía María opencast copper mine. One of the local mayors claimed that this second time death also resulted from a police bullet, in spite of instructions issued by the interior minister that no live ammunition should be used in dealing with protest demonstrations. See: http://www.reuters.com/article/2015/05/05/peru-southern-copper-protests-idUSL1N0XW20020150505
The gravity of the situation at Tía María then pushed the Ombudsman to announce a major initiative to reinitiate dialogue. Those taking part included the minister of energy and mines, the minister of agriculture, the governor of Arequipa and the three local mayors. http://www.peruviantimes.com/06/tia-maria-copper-project-at-the-negotiation-table-again/24184/
Why has this conflict got so far out of control, and what does it tell us?
First, it is widely claimed that Southern Peru Copper took less care in consulting local people than have other companies in similar delicate situations, such as those at Toromocho in Junín and Las Bambas in Apurímac (Economist Ismael Muñoz, interview 6 May 2015).
Second, the Tambo valley, threatened by the possibility of contamination of water supplies and agriculture, is one which has seen huge growth and inward migration in recent years. It now produces new crops such as onions and garlic, in addition to seeing an expansion of sugar cane, rice, maize and potato production.
Third, the area is ‘subtropical desert’ and producers rely heavily on irrigation. This not only brings vulnerability, but also results in the need for organisation in managing irrigation schemes. This experience in collective action has probably enhanced the robust community response.
Fourth, the extent of organisation is also a function of relatively high income levels. Though there is still much poverty, the production units include some substantial properties (as much as 1,000 hectares), and with a ‘typical’ holding ranging from 3 to 10 hectares.
Fifth, as much as 72% of the area of the Tambo river basin is under concession to mining interests.
As Muñoz argues, these are not communities likely to be passive faced with such a very real threat, given their past, their situation today and the priority afforded to mining by government policy. He recommends the formation of a Development Council with solid representation of all actors, able to produce a funded plan to ensure sustainable development for the valley. Let’s hope that the current talks produce such a constructive outcome.
Recent Comments