Amid the sad news from last week (see recent article on Las Bambas), the approval of four items for the regulation of the Forestry and Fauna Law (297663) is a source of optimism. The law recognises for the first time the role of indigenous peoples in forestry management through their participation in the Servicio Nacional Forestal y de Fauna Silvestre (Serfo). Furthermore, the regulations are the result of four years of consensus-building with indigenous communities under the auspices of another legislative advance, the Law on Prior Consultation. But that’s not all. The National Strategy on Climate Change was approved and the Strategy on Forests and Climate Change is now up for public consultation. Last weekend, President Humala was at the United Nations explaining Peru’s commitment to tackling these challenges.
Without wanting to downplay this good news, it is important to remember that a commitment on paper is not enough, however positive. Proper management of our forests requires a permanent presence, administrative creativity, intersectoral action and resolve on the part of the state. While protected areas may benefit from clear regulations, the Servicio Nacional de Areas Naturales Protegidas (Sernamp) lacks the capacity to control deforestation and pollution especially in the zones round the edges of these reserves. To give an example, the zone around the National Reserve of Allpahuayo Mishana has been used by the municipality of Maynas [in northern Peru] as a dumping ground for waste since 2007, even for dangerous waste from hospitals. Outside designated reserves, the forest is a no-man’s land. In less than five years, oil palm concessions have led to the deforestation of 9,000 hectares of virgin forest.
As the four years of negotiation of regulation to the Forestry Law show, success in policy implementation is the best guarantee of future success. On the one hand, clearly there are different visions about what to do with forested areas; some prioritise their economic use, other conservation. However, without public debate, it is not possible to reach a balance between these two positions. On the other hand, to turn the role of the state from having a commitment on paper to being a real actor with the ability to connect multisectoral budget allocations geared towards specific purposes with resolute state presence on the ground requires political will. Laws exist, resources too (the Norwegian and German governments have allocated Peru US$300 million to reduce forestry-induced greenhouse gases). What’s missing is the political commitment to push policy in the right direction.
Translated from an article in ‘Es Hora’. For the Spanish original see http://www.esahora.pe/leyes-para-los-bosques-leyes-de-papel/
Recent Comments