This week the Inter American Human Rights Court (IAHRC) held hearings in Montevideo in which the Government of Peru stood accused of violating the right to subsistence of the Mashco Piro people. If upheld, it will strengthen the legal framework of international indigenous and human rights and open the way for other peoples that likewise face threats from extractive activities, deforestation and infrastructure projects.
The case has been brought by the Madre de Dios regional indigenous organisation (FENAMAD), the national Amazonian indigenous organisation (AIDESEP) and the NGO Earth Rights International.
The Mashco Piro are considered the largest remaining group in voluntary isolation in the Amazon. They inhabit a territory that stretches from the Upper Madre de Dios region in the south-eastern Peru and across the frontier to the Chandless River in Brazil. While the Ministry for Culture estimates their population to be 750 persons, locals familiar with the Mashco Piro and their movements claim that the population is much larger, between 5,000 and 7,000.
Their voluntary isolation dates from the time of the Amazonian rubber boom at the beginning of the 20th century when they fled into the remote areas of the rainforest in response to violence, slavery, persecution and displacement. There they move constantly, hunting, fishing, collecting and constructing temporary camps.
However, the relentless expansion of the extractive frontier has meant that in recent decades there have been an increasing number of incursions into their territory by loggers and gold miners, resulting in violent confrontations. They face risks of decimation by diseases to which they have no immunological defence.
Pressure from neighbouring indigenous communities and organisations eventually led to the creation in 2002 of the Madre de Dios Territorial Reserve, a protected area of 816,057 hectares. State approval of logging concessions within the territory has undermined this protection. This situation has worsened since 2006 when Congress approved legislation permitting the exploitation of natural resources in their territory when considered to be of “public need”.
Following a confrontation between loggers and indigenous in 2005, when two workers were killed, FENAMAD, fearing reprisals, sought urgent protection for the Mashco Piro from the IAHRC. The Court issued precautionary measures in 2007 that remain in place.
In 2011, FENAMAD filed another petition with the Inter-American Human Rights Commission which ruled that the Peruvian government was guilty of violating the rights of the Mashco Piro. Subsequently, following the government’s refusal to comply with the Commission’s recommendations, the case was referred to the Court in 2024.
Meanwhile, in 2016 a multisectoral commission approved a proposal to re-categorise and amplify the reserve by some 240,000 hectares, a recommendation that was never implemented.
Over this period FENAMAD accompanied its legal activism in defence of the rights of the Mashco Piro with a system of community monitoring. Control posts were mounted in strategic locations where trained agents registered the appearances of the Mashco Piro. They confirmed the existence of several clans speaking the same language but with distinct histories and independent patterns of displacement over the territory.
This protective cordon was pierced by trails opened up by the logging industry, clearing the way to unsupervised contacts, often resulting in violent conflict.
The demand presented by FENAMAD and Earth Rights International seeks to protect the survival of the Mashco Piro in the face of the state authorised expansion of extractive activities. The Commission has determined that resource extraction activities and the incursion of outsiders violate the principle of no-contact and the right to voluntary isolation, jeopardising the physical, spiritual and cultural integrity of the Mashco Piro.
Government promotion of extractive projects violates the duty to guarantee the real and effective protection of the Mashco Piros’ fundamental rights.
The organisations representing the victims are asking the state to guarantee the integral protection of their territory. If the Court accepts this demand, it will mark a judicial and political precedent for all Amazonian indigenous peoples. It will reaffirm states’ obligation to implement the measures needed to ensure respect for the no-contact principle and the freedom of peoples to voluntary isolate.
Recent Comments