In an address to Congress on 8 September, Economy and Finance Minister Elmer Cuba pointed to upcoming fiscal difficulties in the event of an El Niño shock and/or a sudden fall in the price of gold. While pointing out that a fiscal take equivalent to only 15% of GDP was insufficient, he argued that the shortfall could be made up from reducing tax evasion or short-term borrowing, with no mention of the need to increase the taxes. He declared that the hike in defence spending this year and next was a one-off and that little had been spent on defence over the last 25 years.
Most analysts concur that the two shocks he mentioned are already making themselves felt. El Niño this year promises to be one of the worst in recent memory. It impacts on most sectors, but most directly on agriculture and fishing. The tax take is almost bound to suffer. As for gold, the price (still at very high levels) has come down notably so far this year from US$5,000 a troy ounce in February to US$4,300 in the first week of September.
Cuba told the Bicameral Budget Commission that with “15% tax pressure there is no way to fulfil all [the] demands” being made on government, especially in areas like health and education which have the largest redistributive impact. He said that the tax yield would therefore need to increase over the coming years, but that in the short run what was needed was to reduce tax evasion. If the external shocks turn out to be severe, he said Peru would have recourse to short-term foreign borrowing.
One of the areas in which the Fujimori government seeks to legislate through delegated powers is in the area of taxation. Cuba had been summoned before the Commission to explain what this would involve. The mooted measures contemplate the simplification and harmonisation of business tax rates, but it remains unclear as to whether this implies an increase or decrease in taxes payable by different economic sectors.
Recent Comments