In the past few weeks, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) issued Judgment No. 01968 2022 PHD TC, providing its most explicit interpretation to date of the constitutional right to be forgotten. The Court defines this right as protecting individuals from the indefinite online circulation of personal information that, although originally viewed as accurate, is no longer accurate or has lost public relevance because of subsequent developments.
The TC further held that the key criterion is not a fixed limitation period, rather whether the information serves any genuine public interest, with the passage of time playing a central role in that assessment.
The case concerned news reports linking a public official to the Rodolfo Orellana criminal network despite subsequent official findings establishing that she lacked any such involvement. The Court ordered the complete removal of the reports, finding that an update was insufficient because more than ten years had elapsed and the publications no longer fulfilled a public interest.
The ruling has implications that extend beyond the case in hand. It establishes a doctrine whose scope could affect cases where information has not been disproved yet is considered insufficiently relevant after the passage of time. By leaving the continuing public interest of information open to judicial assessment, the judgment grants considerable discretion over what may ultimately be removed from the digital record. The TC suggests that only exceptionally serious crimes, including terrorism and drug trafficking, may be of enduring public relevance.
The concern lies in the absence of clear criteria separating genuinely obsolete personal information from accurate reporting that remains important for the purposes of democratic scrutiny. Public officials and other politically powerful actors could invoke this doctrine to seek the removal of older material concerning institutional conduct, corruption, human rights violations, or political responsibility, even where that material remains relevant for understanding broader historical patterns.
This is particularly significant in Peru, where digital news archives often preserve information that is otherwise difficult to access and where public memory of authoritarianism, corruption, and state violence remains politically contested. As Peru prepares for the incoming administration of Keiko Fujimori, the decision invites reflection on how the right to be forgotten will evolve in practice.
Recent Comments