The Constitutional Tribunal has finally ruled, after years of delay during which Congress authorised massive fiscal spending, to close the door from now onwards. The decision, taken by the TC on 10 July, three weeks in advance of Fuerza Popular (FP) taking over the presidency, will restrict the ability of Congress to spend public resources without restraint. According to Ojo Público, 16 of these congressional decisions cost the Treasury no less than 110.6 billion new soles (or around about US$31.2 billion).
From now on, the Congress will be unable to pass spending laws unless with the explicit approval of the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF). This will restore the fiscal discipline that was in place until October 2022 when the TC published a resolution that authorised congressional spending initiatives. Readers will recall that it was in 2022 that FP and its allies in Congress voted in new members of the TC closely aligned with their political views.
FP members of Congress supported costly tax measures designed to benefit business elites. Typical was the so-called Ley Chlimper 2.0 (Law 3234) that gave generous tax exonerations for up to ten years to large-scale agricultural exporters. This is reckoned to have cost the Treasury 1.8 billion new soles a year. Another case was Law 31556 that reduced sales tax for the owners of hotels and restaurants costing an estimated 1.4 billion between 2022 and 2024.
More recently, Law 32561, which increased the pensions for members of the armed forces and police is estimated by Ojo Público to have costed 14.8 billion soles while Law 31495 offering a bonus to teachers cost 40.6 billion.
In the build-up to this year’s general election, FP members of Congress and their allies approved a further eight bills costing a further 18 billion soles according to the Consejo Fiscal, a treasury watchdog. In June, Congress was debating a supplementary credit of a further 10 billion new soles. The former economy minister, Luis Miguel Castilla, is quoted as saying that “never have I seen in the last weeks before a change of government, that a supplementary credit of this magnitude being discussed”.
The recent about-turn in the position of the TC had its origins in a demand by the Boluarte administration in 2023 against a law passed by Congress obliging the government to spend on housing in Loreto region when there was no budget allocation to cover the costs. The TC decision – after a delay of three years – upheld the executive complaint. From now on, not only will spending initiatives have to coordinate with the MEF but will need to show where the funding will come from.
Article 79 of the 1993 constitution states quite clearly that spending initiatives by the Congress are unconstitutional. “The representatives in Congress do not have the power to create or increase public spending, except that relating to its own budget” it states, and that “laws relating to taxation relating to benefits or exonerations require the prior approval of the Ministry of Economy and Finance”.
The TC decision will be binding from now onwards on the bicameral parliament that will be installed shortly, both on the Chamber of Deputies and the Senate. The boot now appears to be on the other foot.
Recent Comments