Hot on the heels of last week’s story on increasing levels of illegal activities in the Amazon, two new reports on organised crime, especially along the frontier with Brazil, are raising concerns about the risk of government inaction ceding de facto sovereignty over wide areas of national territory.

A new report by a consortium of national and regional indigenous organisations (AIDESEP and ORAU) and national and international NGOs has documented the increased level of illegal activities, especially illicit gold mining and drug trafficking. These raise the possibility of the government losing effective control over the territory unless the next government takes drastic measures in coordination with frontline indigenous communities.

Organised crime, fuelled by high gold prices and uncontrolled drug trafficking (especially in border areas), has turned the Peruvian Amazon into a refuge zone and the base for ever-expanding criminal networks. The authors of the report attribute this to various factors: the lack of secure land titles for communities; a weak state presence; and the absence of effective mechanisms to protect indigenous leaders and environmental defenders from increased levels of violence.

They argue that some of the most effective measures taken to confront the advance of criminal activities have included territorial monitoring, the existence of indigenous self-defence forces (guardias indigenas), and other mechanisms to provide for community control.

They say that the next government should abandon strategies centred only on coca eradication, militarisation and interdiction, and instead enable indigenous to have territorial governance. They argue that the state needs to restore capacities undermined by recent legal reforms and to reinforce regional cooperation with neighbouring countries.

Finally, they highlight the importance of integrated development strategies that bring together security, respect for human rights, and the fight against deforestation. Decisions taken by the new government will determine whether this deteriorating situation can be stopped and reversed or whether the systems of territorial power that undermine sovereignty and capture local institutions will continue to gain sway.

A second report, published on 6 May, by a combination of Peruvian and Brazilian indigenous organisations in coordination with Earth Insight, a US-based NGO, reveals the overlapping of the Yavari-Tapiche Territorial Corridor by oil, mining and logging concessions, highway projects, and illegal activities.

The Corridor, which runs from north to south along the Brazilian Peruvian border, contains the largest concentration of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation in South America. It covers some 16 million hectares (twice the size of Panama) and includes ten indigenous peoples on the Peruvian side alone.

Employing geospatial analysis and testimonies from communities along the length of the corridor, the study documents the presence of petroleum and gas blocks, illegal logging, illegal mining and a growing network of overlapping roads overlapping covering the frontier states of Amazonas and Acre in Brazil and the Loreto and Ucayali regions in Peru.

Some 90% of the rainforest on the Brazilian side comprises protected areas while the Peruvian side comprises national parks and protected areas that overlap indigenous reserves. Oil and gas blocks overlap 1.7 million hectares, or 10% percent the territory, of which 669,000 hectares (almost one-third of the total Corridor) have high levels of biodiversity. There are also 13 mining concessions and on the Peruvian side and 500,000 hectares of logging concessions.

For every kilometre of legal roads there are 3 kilometres of illegal ones. There are also two road building proposals that would run through the Corridor. The first would connect Cruzeiro do Sul on the Brazilian side with Pucallpa in Peru, endangering peoples in voluntary isolation in the Isconahua Indigenous Reserve and conservation areas in the Sierra del Divisor cordillera. The other would connect Jenaro Herrera in Loreto region with Colonia Angamos near the Brazilian border, an area virtually controlled by criminal gangs, illegal miners and smugglers.

The authors present suggestions for protecting the Corridor. One is to strengthen indigenous governance; another to dismantle criminal networks on indigenous lands; and a third is to strengthen indigenous monitoring teams and integrate them directly with state programmes and agencies.

In addition, the report recommends investing in social and bioeconomic activities in indigenous communities to replace extractive industries; investment in infrastructure (such as electricity, digital connectivity and equipment for improving community monitoring and protection); and the elimination of concessions and establishment of zones free from extractive industries and large-scale industries.