In a widely expected move, the right-wing parties in Congress approved a motion on 3 December barring Delia Espinoza from public office for ten years. This is a severe rebuff to judicial independence as the Congress seeks to impose itself not just on the executive power but on the judiciary. Espinoza had for months valiantly fought back congressional attempts to control the public prosecution service which she headed since late 2024.
Initially the report by the Sub-Commission of Constitutional Accusations (SAC) failed to win approval by the necessary 68 votes. But following a repeat vote, requested by two far right members (Jorge Montoya and Norma Yarrow), it was passed in a highly expedited fashion by 71 votes. A number of members changed their minds while others who had not voted previously responded to the call to ditch Espinoza. The president of Congress, Fernando Rospigliosi, a key figure in Fuerza Popular, cut short debate prior to the second vote.
Espinoza has fought off attacks for the best part of a year. As well as from Congress itself these emanated from the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) whose members responded to the call from Congress. It was Congress which appointed Josue Gutiérrez as Defensor del Pueblo, and it was he who was responsible for selecting the members of the JNJ.
As readers will recall, in recent weeks the JNJ refused to respond to the ruling of a judge ordering Espinoza to be reinstated as chief public prosecutor. Her replacement, Tomás Gálvez, is reputed to have links to the criminal network known as ‘Los Cuellos Blancos del Puerto’.
Espinoza’s removal represents the loss of an important piece in the chess game to maintain judicial independence. Her defence lawyer who represented her in the debate in Congress pointed to the fact that of the 16 members of the Permanent Commission that had previously approved the SAC report, 15 were subject to ongoing investigations by the public prosecution service.
Ostensibly, Espinoza’s offence was to oppose a law that transferred responsibility for investigating crime from the prosecution service (which forms part of the judiciary) to the police force (which depends on the executive).
Tellingly, Montoya in his justification for Espinoza’s removal highlighted that “It is unacceptable that she dared to threaten the representatives of the nation (…) Her insistence on denouncing members of Congress in the exercise of their functions is disproportionate and belligerent”. He went on to say that opening investigations into members was “a public danger”.
Prior to the vote, Congress also approved the removal of the judicial protection (fuero) enjoyed by Espinoza, meaning that she can now be investigated for criminal actions by the service she previously led.
According to Congresswoman Sigrid Bazán, who will address the PSG conference this Saturday, “the barring of the prosecutor Delia Espinoza is a judicial absurdity (depropósito), reflecting only political vengeance”.
Recent Comments