In a surprise decision on 4 September, the Multisectoral Commission for Peoples in Voluntary Isolation rejected by eight votes to five the Additional Categorising Study for the creation of the Yavarí Mirim Indigenous Reserve, thereby ending a process aimed at creating the reserve that had taken almost twenty years. It is not clear at this stage whether this is the final decision over the creation of the reserve and, if not, what measures can be taken to amend or appeal it.
Those that voted to reject the report included the representatives of the Ministry for Energy and Mines, the Ministry for Agriculture, the Ministry for Defence, the Interior Ministry, the Loreto regional government and the Marshal Ramón Castilla, Requena and Maynas provincial governments.
The representatives from the Defensoría, the anthropology departments of the Catholic and San Marcos Universities, and of from two national indigenous organisations (AIDESEP and CONAP) voted to approve the study. The meeting was chaired by the representative of the Ministry for Culture. Representatives from the Environment, Health and Education Ministries did not attend.
This decision leaves the Matsés, Matis, Korubo, Kukina Pano and Flecheiro/Tavakina indigenous peoples living in voluntary isolation in a vulnerable situation. They had previously been recognised as existing by the Commission. The dangers they face have increased due to the advances in both legal and illegal extractive activities and the expansion of deforestation.
Between 2021 and 2024, almost 32,000 hectares of forest were lost due to deforestation in the Yavarí-Tapiche territorial corridor. And between the beginning of 2025 and 9 August, 137,167 deforestation alerts were registered in the area.
On 5 September, AIDESEP and CONAP were joined by the Loreto regional indigenous organisation ORPIO in publishing a communique in which they expressed their deeply-felt rejection of the state’s decision. This was taken despite a series of studies and reports going back over 20 years, as well as the presentation of 113 new anthropological pieces of evidence, including the existence of 25 settlements confirmed by high resolution satellite images.
They also condemned the irregular participation in the meeting of Congressman Juan Carlos Celis Mori, author of various initiatives that have questioned the existence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. He was behind a bill to modify the law governing indigenous peoples in isolation that would require reserves to be subject to periodic revisions, with a view to reducing them or eliminating them altogether given their supposed negative impacts on regional and national development.
The Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) has reaffirmed its support for the indigenous organisations defending the rights of indigenous peoples in isolation and is urging the state to comply with its obligation to protect their lives and traditional territories.
Recent Comments