Within less than a month since his return to the cabinet as justice minister, Juan José Santiváñez has unveiled plans to rebuild Peru’s notorious island jail – often described as Peru’s Devil’s Island – to house major criminals. The hugely expensive project seems to respond more to the minister’s desire to portray himself as ‘tough on crime’ than a thought-out policy to increase capacity in Peru’s grossly overcrowded jails. The project is also being promoted by President Dina Boluarte who paraded before the cameras there earlier this week.

The site has been in ruins ever since 1986 when the then García government destroyed it in an attempt to put down protests by Sendero Luminoso inmates. It lies offshore from the port of Callao, where tricky ocean currents make escape particularly difficult. The prison was rebuilt in the early 1980s by the Belaunde government, having fallen into disuse. Historically it was used to house leading political prisoners, becoming a powerful symbol of the repression wrought by successive authoritarian governments.

According to sources from the Instituto Nacional Penitenciario (INPE), rebuilding El Frontón would cost some 5 billion soles. For this amount, they say, 20 prisons could be built which would resolve the problem of overcrowding in Peru’s penitentiary system. It would also require incurring the ongoing costs of becoming a maximum-security establishment. According to Santiváñez, these estimates are exaggerated, and the costs would be met in part by the private sector through the ‘obras por impuestos’ scheme whereby investors receive tax relief for construction of public works. He claimed that construction would take 8-10 months.