President Dina Boluarte’s discourse to the Congress and the nation during the Independence Day celebrations on 28 July sought to inspire confidence in an ailing administration in its last year. It did not. Outside on the streets of Lima and other cities a different reality imposed itself with demonstrations of rejection towards a president whose popularity ratings are below 3%.

The speech, more than four hours in length, narrated the supposed achievements of her period in office, much of it a routine description – ministry by ministry – of public works realised. Many of the promises made in her previous annual allocution remain unfulfilled. Boluarte made no attempt at self-criticism, seeking simply to portray the president as saviour of the nation from what she termed ‘traitors to the fatherland’, ignoring the fact that she had been elected vice-president on a ticket in 2021 with just those very ‘traitors’. While some in the Congress building fell visibly asleep, several members on the left abandoned it altogether in protest at Boluarte’s accusations.

Rather than the president, it was the Archbishop of Lima, Carlos Castillo, who struck the most poignant note in his earlier homily in the Cathedral to which the president, as tradition demands, attended. He made clear allusion to the problems facing the great majority of Peruvians and the failings of the political class to remedy them. He denounced, in the clearest possible tones, the problems of corruption and power, alluding to the “mafioso spirit” within Peru’s rulers and the lack of any vocation of public service.

“Then let us all be self-critical, let us acknowledge that a broad section of our national leadership lives in denial of the majority and only see their own interests” he said “our people see that those who act out of a vocation for service are few, and they see clearly that the mafioso spirit has taken over their hearts, causing them to be guided by an egotistical and tyrannical spirit” (our translation). Castillo went on to address Boluarte in unmistakably personal terms, saying say that while it is easy to be a dictator, being a good governor is far harder.

While Boluarte addressed Congress, outside police battled with protestors demanding justice for the killings that took place across southern Peru in December 2022 in the days after Boluarte took power from ousted President Pedro Castillo (who remains in jail). There were several injuries. In her speech Boluarte referred to the 2022 protests as the work of “golpistas” (coup mongers).

From the Barbadillo jail, Castillo enunciated his own Independence Day message (via X). “They have not silenced me, the voice of the people remains alive”, he said “I will never stop giving voice to the oppressed”.