Recent rulings by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) and the Inter-American Human Rights Court (IAHRC) regarding states’ responsibility for defending the right to a clean environment and respecting the rights of nature, have created an auspicious environment for two ambitious agreements signed by indigenous organisations with international actors. These aim at consolidating human and environmental rights.

On 3 July, the IAHRC issued an Opinion that established clearly, and for the first time, that the climate crisis represents a threat to human rights and that states have concrete and immediate obligations to protect both people and the environment. This ruling applies to over 30 member countries of the Organization of American States.

This decision recognises nature as enjoying rights and will allow litigants to sue states and corporations that potentially damage a healthy climate. It establishes a precedent, potentially applicable globally. According to the Court, states must not only abstain from causing significant environmental damage but also adopt measures to guarantee the protection, restoration and regeneration of ecosystems.

On the heels of this pronouncement, on 23 July, the ICJ declared that climate change is an “existential universal risk” unquestionably generated by human activities and that member states have the duty to prevent it. This means that, under international law, all states are obliged to protect the global climate system and those states responsible for generating climate change are obliged to repair the damage caused to affected states.

In April 2023, at the urging of small island states in the Pacific, the UN General Assembly requested that the ICJ define states’ obligations to guarantee the protection of the climate system in the face of human-generated emissions and the legal consequences of these obligations for states.

As a result of the ruling, any state held responsible for contributing to climate change must cease its illicit actions or omissions, provide guarantees not to repeat the actions if the circumstances require it, and provide restitution, indemnity and satisfaction to affected states.

The ICJ has also ruled that these obligations form part of customary international law and, as such, are applicable to all states, whether or not they are party to international climate agreements. They also apply to present and future generations affected by the adverse effects of climate change.

These two rulings by regional and international courts represent a significant change in the legal context within which states are expected to operate in the future. Over time, they should strengthen the protection of those more vulnerable to environmental damage and climate change, especially of indigenous peoples.

In this context, on 17 July in Geneva, the Peruvian government, the presidents of the principal Amazonian indigenous organisations, and representatives of Mercuria Energy Group (a Swiss energy corporation) signed two agreements intended to strengthen the defence of indigenous and environmental rights in the Peruvian Amazon.

The first is a pioneering initiative, on which we reported previously, to establish the groundwork for the implementation of a Jurisdictional Indigenous REDD+ HFLD (High Forest, Low Deforestation) Programme. This programme is intended to establish a climate strategy that will be not only effective but also grounded in the ancestral knowledge of indigenous people and respect for their rights.

It will cover some 7 million hectares in the Loreto, Amazonas and Ucayali regions, of which 91% corresponds to 923 indigenous communities and 9% to five communal reserves.

The second agreement signed between the indigenous organisations and the Mercuria corporation obliges Mercuria to fund the implementation of the programme aimed at the conservation and management of the rainforest under community leadership. The indigenous organisations hope that this agreement will provide an opportunity to strengthen their governance capacities. They also hope that this alliance with Mercuria Trading and its Silvania Mechanism will help ensure the conservation and sustainable use of the forests.

While this all sounds very promising, REDD initiatives, which involve private funding for environmental and/or social programmes to compensate for greenhouse gas emissions, have long been controversial. Further, according to a recent publication, Mercuria has joint ventures with Integra Capital, an investment fund owned by José Luis Manzano, an Argentine businessman and former minister in the government of Carlos Menem. Manzano has been investigated for money laundering, tax evasion and espionage, although none of these activities have involved Mercuria. Manzano is owner of the Peruvian mining company Volcan, part owner of the Chancay port through Inversiones Portuarias Chancay and, more recently, Empresa Telefónica del Perú.