It has been a week of new challenges to the judicial order perpetrated by the former chief public prosecutor, Patricia Benavides. According to her critics, these changes place Peru’s already battered democracy in further jeopardy. On 16 June, Benavides, accompanied by henchmen, sought to physically take over the offices of the current chief prosecutor, Delia Espinoza. Benavides is closely aligned with the parties of the far right in Congress in seeking to quash investigations into members of Congress and President Dina Boluarte.

According to El País, Benavides was supported in her attempted assault on the Ministerio Público by members of La Resistencia, the far-right shock group. While the crowd danced to the sound of the ‘Ritmo del Chino’ (the emblematic jingle associated with former president Alberto Fujimori), workers in the ministry managed to block their entry into the building. Benavides exited by the back door.

As we noted last week, the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ), issued a controversial ruling restoring Benavides to the position of chief public prosecutor (Fiscal de la Nación) notwithstanding the fact that the position is already occupied by Espinoza. This was in direct contravention to Article 158 of the Constitution that states explicitly that the Fiscal de la Nación is appointed by the group of senior fiscales (Junta de Fiscales Supremos).

This week, in response to the challenge from the JNJ, the Junta issued a statement categorically rejecting the power of the JNJ to remove Espinoza and arguing irregularities in the process. They claimed that Benavides’ conduct “was a threat to the institutionality [of the Ministerio Público]” and an attempt to challenge its autonomy. Apart from Espinoza herself, the Junta is made up by three respected former chief public prosecutors: Pablo Sánchez, Juan Carlos Villena and Zoraida Avalos.

For its part, the far-right Renovación Popular party, led by Lima Mayor Rafael López Aliaga, put a motion before Congress exhorting the JNJ to dismiss the members of the Junta, arguing that it was they who had violated the constitution and defied the JNJ.

Last October, the previous members of the JNJ – they were subsequently replaced by members closely aligned with the majority in Congress – voted formally to dismiss Benavides from her position in the Ministerio Público because of her role in manipulating appointments and issuing decisions to protect members of Congress from accusations of corruption. The election of the new JNJ was widely criticised for its lack of transparency. It was organised at the behest of Josué Gutiérrez, the ombudsman, whose own appointment by Congress has also been questioned.

On 19 June, Espinoza issued a criminal denunciation against Benavides for seeking to enter the building of the Ministerio Público and forcing her way up to the ninth floor where the office of the Fiscal de la Nación is located. Responding to the denunciation, Benavides’ lawyer – the former Aprista prime minister Jorge Del Castillo – rejected the claim.

In his response to the challenge by Benavides, Prime Minister Eduardo Arana offered the services of the executive as a way to resolve what he called “a crisis” in the Ministerio Público. Espinoza denied that there was any crisis as such, only an assault by Benavides and those backing her.

According to the former members of the Constitutional Tribunal, Marianella Ledesma (in an interview with La Mula), said “The Fiscalía is the only entity that, due to its constitutional design, can investigate and hold responsible officials of the judicial power. Boluarte has five denunciations [against her], various members of Congress as well, Benavides herself has been denounced as a member of a criminal organization. All have something in common. They want to capture the Fiscalía to ensure their impunity”.

Meanwhile, last week’s JNJ resolution also demanded the reincorporation into the Ministerio Público of Tomás Gálvez. He was dismissed in 2021 over his supposed links to the ‘Cuellos Blancos del Puerto’, a case relating to high level corruption in the port of Callao. He denies the charges and claims to be a victim of political persecution.