At a time when indigenous communities and organisations in the Amazon are increasingly promoting the creation of Regional Conservation Areas (RCAs) as a tool to conserve natural areas and resources and securing indigenous livelihoods, SERFOR, the National Forestry and Wildlife Service, has proposed new regulations which would reserve the conservation of fragile ecosystems exclusively for the state.

Since the development in the 19th century of the idea that wilderness areas – understood as regions where nature could be conserved free from the presence of humans – the relations between the state and indigenous peoples over who should be responsible for conservation have been fraught.

In the case of Peru, the idea that indigenous peoples should be excluded from areas designated for conservation, many of which had traditionally been the source of their livelihoods and sustainably managed by them, has over time given way to the creation of a complex system of natural protected areas with varying degrees of state and indigenous management control.

Indigenous organisations in the Amazon regard the RCAs as legal entities that allow them to manage, together with the state, their traditional territories and establish an indigenous monitoring system to ensure their conservation. They argue that indigenous peoples have historically protected these territories and ecosystems and that the RCA model is fully compatible with their sustainable management.

As a result, there are now some ten proposals to establish RCAs awaiting approval, with the support of indigenous communities and organisations.

However, on 28 April, SERFOR repealed a regulation that stated that, in the instance of an overlap between an RCA and a fragile ecosystem, the creation of the RCA would not be considered a threat to the fragile ecosystem. By annulling this norm, SERFOR as generated uncertainty for 13 proposals for the creation of RCAs that overlap fragile ecosystems in seven regions of the country.

In response, six indigenous organisations along the Putumayo River accused SERFOR of placing obstacles in the process of the creation of RCAs led by indigenous peoples. They charged that SERFOR’s action violated their fundamental right to manage their ancestral lands. They demanded that the legal recognition of their conservation initiatives be guaranteed, that the work of communal monitoring committees be supported, and that the communities’ wish sustainably to manage their territories be respected.

A delegation comprising representatives of eight indigenous organisations travelled to Lima in the first week of June to demand effective protection for the Putumayo watershed. The principal objective of the delegation was to promote immediate and effective actions to protect their territories. To this end they proposed the installation of a high-level technical working group, with participation from the Prime Minister’s Office and other relevant ministries.

In the midst of this debate, the Ministry of the Environment (Minam) announced the creation of the Medio Putumayo Algodón RCA to protect 283,000 hectares of Amazonian rainforest. This represents a milestone in the protection of ecosystems and the defence of indigenous territories against deforestation, illegal mining and wildlife trafficking.

It is estimated that the loss of almost 46,000 hectares of primary forest over the next 20 years will be avoided. As well, a significant contribution would be made to the carbon stock of the Loreto region that represents 53% of the national total. Further, the new RCA will benefit over 5,000 persons in 16 indigenous communities from seven ethnic groups who depend on the natural resources of the area for 75% of their subsistence. The communities have been seeking the creation of this RCA since 2016.

It is hoped that this RCA will form a key part of a future Trans-Border Biological and Cultural Corridor connecting over 3.5 million hectares of forest in Peru, Ecuador and Colombia. This corridor would include the Yaguas National Park, the Ampiyacu and Maijuna Kichwa CRAs and the proposed Ere-Campuya Conservation Area.

The creation of the new CRA has been supported by the Loreto regional government, Minam and SERNANP (the national parks service), in association with the Instituto de Bien Común (IBC), the Peruvian Environmental Law Society (SPDA) and Conservation International Peru (CI Peru) and several international NGOs.

These contradictory measures have led the SPDA to suggest that “an open debate will be needed between authorities to review their responsibilities, exchange information and unite their efforts to achieve the participatory and, above all, effective management that takes into account both the conservation values identified by technical studies and also the needs and sustainable use that the population and communities can give to these ecosystems.”