The Constitutional Tribunal (TC) has ruled unconstitutional a municipal ordinance of the Ucayali-Contamana province that denies the existence of indigenous peoples in voluntary isolation. The decision was a response to a demand presented in 2023 by the Lima and Callao Association pf Sociologists, in association with the national Amazonian indigenous organisation AIDESEP and the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL).
This decision represents an important step towards the protection of the fundamental rights of the country’s most vulnerable population. These peoples, who minimise their contacts with the larger population for historical and health reasons, are those most vulnerable to the advance of extractive activities, epidemics and territorial conflicts.
The ordinance sought to exclude the province from the law protecting peoples in voluntary isolation by expressly denying their existence in the province. It looked to exclude the province from any proposal to create natural protected areas or indigenous reserves for peoples in isolation.
The TC argued that no local authority can annul fundamental rights or ignore national and international norms, and stressed that the identification and recognition of peoples in isolation is the exclusive prerogative of the Ministry of Culture. The TC also ratified that peoples in voluntary isolation enjoy collective rights that are recognised in the Constitution and by international agreements such as ILO Convention 169.
Finally, the TC emphasized that the territories of people in voluntary isolation are intangible, meaning that they cannot be affected by activities that place their survival at risk.
In the Peruvian Amazon it is estimated that there are 7,500 indigenous in voluntary isolation belonging to at least 25 ethnic groups. Currently there are eight legally recognised reserves for their protection. These reserves cover some 4.5 million hectares. In addition, there are five proposals for classifying additional reserves. These would cover a further 3.5 million hectares.
Such reserves, many of which lack sufficient funding for effective monitoring and protection, were created by the state to guarantee the right to life, voluntary isolation and self-determination.
The TC’s decision is interpreted as an attempt to put a stop to narratives promoted by some public authorities and private sector interests.
Recent Comments