We have been reporting on the long-standing conflict between the Cordillera Azul National Park and the communities on whose territories the park was established. A recent court case victory by the indigenous communities represents an important milestone.

Indigenous organisations in the San Martín region are celebrating the decision by a court in Tarapoto that orders the titling of territories overlapped by the Cordilleras Azul National Park and the Cordillera Escalera Regional Conservation Area. In doing so, the court has recognised the communities’ right to the possession of their ancestral lands which were partially incorporated into the two protected areas without consultation or consent.

The lawsuit was presented by a coalition of local, regional and national indigenous organisations in the face of the refusal of the national parks authority (SERNANP) and the head of the Cordillera Azul National Park to comply with norms authorising the titling of territories within natural protected areas. The court’s decision reflects the view that there is no explicit legal norm that impedes the titling of community lands that overlap with natural protected areas.

This form of state-backed territorial alienation reflects a partial and distorted vision of conservation sometimes referred to as ‘exclusive conservation’ or ‘fortress conservation’ that ignores the prior presence of the communities and treats them as obstacles to environmental conservation. The decision reaffirms the position that conservation and indigenous peoples’ land rights are not incompatible.

According to the constitutional lawyer Juan Carlos Ruiz Molleda, in an opinion piece indigenous peoples should not be seen as enemies of the environment or potential deforesters but rather as guardians of the forest, long-term defenders of these ecosystems and as those with the greatest  interest in their conservation.

This ruling may set a precedent for future cases involving the overlap between indigenous territories and natural protected areas.