In a shift of the position it took late last year, the Defensoría del Pueblo, led by Josué Gutiérrez, has decided that it favours impunity for those accused of crimes against humanity committed prior to 2002. Carlos Fernández, the deputy ombudsman, justified this decision on the basis of the length of time since those crimes were committed. He thereby expressed support for a bill before Congress to extend impunity to those held guilty of such crimes.

Fernández was taking part in a roundtable convened by the constitution commission in Congress, led by prominent Fuerza Popular member Fernando Rospigliosi. The bill in support of impunity was sponsored by Jorge Montoya, a former admiral who in 2007-08 headed up the Joint Command of the Armed Forces.

Gutiérrez, a supporter of Perú Libre (PL), the erstwhile left-wing party that backed the candidacy of Pedro Castillo in the 2021 presidential election, was elected to the position of Defensor by an alliance of congressional members including PL and parties of the far right, notably Fuerza Popular (FP). As Defensor, Gutiérrez has wavered in his support for human rights issues.

This latest decision, voiced on 22 April, provides further evidence of Gutiérrez’s proximity to FP. In its opinion paper, published last November, the Defensoría argued against Montoya’s bill citing international humanitarian law on such matters.

On a separate matter, Gutiérrez, in an appearance before the Constitutional Tribunal, argued that only the Congress can investigate a sitting president, not the Public Ministry. Boluarte’s lawyers have sought to argue before the TC that the constitution prevents a president from being investigated. This did not prevent investigations into Boluarte’s predecessor, Pedro Castillo.

It would seem that Article 117 prevents a president from being formally accused, not investigated.