On March 19, the Criminal Appeals Chamber of the Superior Court of Justice of Apurímac began the appeal hearing against eleven environmental defenders from Cotabambas, who face sentences of up to nine years in prison for their part in protests against MMG Las Bambas. The initial ruling, made on July 25, 2024, also imposed a civil reparation of 50,000 new soles payable to the state and US$88,600 to the mining company.
The case dates back to September 2015, when the police (PNP), under a private security agreement with MMG Las Bambas, intervened in a demonstration protesting about modifications to the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) that had been made without prior consultation. As a result, three community members lost their lives with another death occurring subsequently in 2016. To date, no judicial proceedings have been brought against members of the police force or company executives. More than 300 people were charged, with eleven convicted.
Among the defendants were Virginia Pinares Ochoa, recipient of the National Human Rights Award in 2022, along with various community leaders such as Rodolfo Abarca Quispe, Juan Pablo Cconislla Gallegos and Maximiliano Huachaca Mamani. In November 2019, the Peru Support Group hosted Virginia Pinares on a visit to London. She was a guest speaker at our annual conference.
The prosecution has accused the eleven of disturbances and other offenses against property and security, while the defence has argued a lack of conclusive evidence and has pointed out irregularities in the trial process.
The decision of the appeals court is crucial in determining the fate of the eleven defenders and their potential acquittal. The trial comes within a broader debate on balancing the right to protest against that need for security.
Recent Comments