The plan to construct the Ariana copper and zinc mine has long been a bone of contention because of the possible environmental impacts on the headwaters of the river system feeding Lima. The legal dispute, which has raged for a decade, has now reached a critical phase. On 7 March, both sides in contention laid out their arguments at a hearing and the judge is expected to give her verdict in the coming days.

Located in the district of Marcapomacocha in the province of Yauli, Junín region at 4,400 metres above sea level, the project consists of developing a subterranean mine and a processing plant whose capacity would be 2,000 tonnes a day. The company involved, Southern Peaks Mining, hopes to begin construction work this year with the view to extraction starting in 2027.

The objections to Ariana relate to its proximity to the tunnel that brings water through the high Andes to provide an important part of Lima’s water supply. The project is also thought likely to affect both superficial and underground water sources thus threatening the purity of water supply. José de Echave, the former vice-minister for the environment and key figure in CooperAcción, has raised the question of what would happen if the tailings dam ruptured. “Dams can collapse, in Peru and in the world” he says, pointing this as a danger to the supply of water to 11 million Limeños.

For its part, the Instituto de Defensa Legal (IDL) has asked the judge to take into account earlier legal rulings from last year that advocate the annulment of resolutions approving the Environmental Impact Assessment (EIA) for the project and the ordering of an international study to analyse the possible dangers. In additions, lawyers for Sedapal, the Lima water authority, expressed concerns about the lack of alternative sources of water if the tunnel under the Andes was affected.

Southern Peaks argues that it has introduced some changes to its original plan which it claims will neutralise objections on environmental grounds. The hearing included lawyers for the Council of Ministers, the Ministry of Energy and Mines and the National Water Authority who argued against the annulment of the rulings approving the EIA.