Under new management since the beginning of the year, the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) has initiated disciplinary proceedings against Janet Tello, the recently appointed head of the judiciary. This has brought protests, amongst them from the Colegio de Abogados de Lima, that she is the target of a witch-hunt following her criticisms of President Dina Boluarte. This appears to be yet another twist in the now long-running saga of the far-right seeking to control the judiciary.

At the end of October, seven new members of the JNJ were sworn in following a selection procedure condemned by human rights and legal groups for its lack of transparency. Their appointment brought a shift in the political calculations of Fuerza Popular (FP), the party which dominates the Justice Commission in Congress and which previously had supported moves to eliminate the JNJ and replace it with a new body. The new JNJ members took office on 6 January with Gino Ríos, the preferred option of FP, as their president.

The disciplinary proceedings against Tello and four other supreme judges came as a consequence of a case instigated by a retired colonel in 2015, which, following several appeals, had been declared inadmissible by the Supreme Court last July. The plaintiff issued a denunciation before the JNJ in November, accusing the judges – among them Tello – of improper procedural conduct. At the end of January, Ríos initiated disciplinary actions against the judges involved in the case.

This JNJ action has caused considerable polemic in legal circles, where such a move is considered inappropriate except in instances of the most serious improper conduct that threatens the stability of the judicial system. This appears to be far from the case in this instance.

The Colegio de Abogados de Lima has issued a statement arguing that Tello is the object of “political harassment” following her moves to defend the independence of the judiciary. It goes on “it is worrying that, out of the thousands of cases resolved by the court of which Dr Tello has formed part in recent years, this particular one is selected as a pretext [in ways that] impact on the workings and independence of the judiciary”. It ends by saying that “such disciplinary measures should not be used as mechanisms of political pressure”.

Tello was elected head of the Supreme Court and president of the judicial branch on 5 December 2024 by no less than ten of the 18 judges on the Court. She promised to uphold the independence of the judiciary from attacks by the far-right in Congress.

In early February, Tello responded to attempts by the executive to wriggle out of accusations levelled at President Dina Boluarte. She argued against Boluarte’s claims that judicial decisions were politically biased, stating her view that the president should devote more of her time to resolving problems like public insecurity that “are really of real interest to citizens”. Boluarte faces judicial investigations on multiple fronts.