The bill to eliminate the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) was returned to the Constitution Commission on 11 December after a vote in Congress in which the Fujimoristas in Fuerza Popular (FP) had second thoughts on the matter. This volte face appears to have been the result of the nomination of new members of the JNJ who take office in January. The same day Congress approved the creation of a special commission on judicial reform.
Dominated by FP, the congressional constitution commission had backed proposals to replace the JNJ’s functions by a new body, the Escuela Nacional de la Magistratura, whose three members would be responsible for nominating and ratifying judges and public prosecutors. The bill would have also given to Congress the role of appointing the heads of the ONPE and the Reniec, two of the three bodies in charge of elections.
The abolition of the JNJ would have involved a constitutional amendment and would therefore have had to be approved by two-thirds of the Congress in two consecutive legislative periods.
The new members of the JNJ are due to take office on 6 January. As readers will recall, the way in which they were chosen has been criticised for its lack of transparency and the mirky role played in the proceedings by the ombudsman, Josué Gutiérrez.
The presidency of the JNJ is the subject of dispute between two candidates, Gino Ríos Patio, the preferred option of FP, and Francisco Távara, a former president of the judiciary and head of the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones. The likelihood of Ríos Patio becoming president of the JNJ points towards this institution coming within the party’s control.
In a parallel move on 11 December, rushed through at the last minute and supported by FP, Congress voted to create a special commission to come up with proposals for a complete overhaul of the judiciary within a maximum of 90 days.
Justified by the lack of public confidence in the judiciary and public prosecution service, the move may have rather different objectives. The Congress itself is an institution in which public confidence is close to zero. It remains unclear who would be involved in such a commission and how it would operate. Similar judicial reform moves have been suggested in the past by Congress but have failed to produce results.
Recent Comments