Politics, organised crime, poverty and energy transition came under the spotlight at the PSG’s Annual Conference held live at the UCL Education Institute in London on 30 November, with trenchant contributions from leading Peruvian experts, activists and academics. Entitled ‘Peru on the Ropes? Democracy, Society and Energy Transition’, this was the first time in five years that the PSG was able to organise a face-to-face meeting. Members new and old attended.

The day began with an analysis of the current political context from PSG chair John Crabtree. The government of President Dina Boluarte, currently enjoying a record-breaking low approval rate of 3%, is at ‘a very low ebb’, he said, even lacking support in the business community now. The parties of the far right have asserted control over the political agenda, corruption has got worse, and the killing of 49 citizens by government forces in the 2022-23 protests remains “an open wound that has not healed at all”.

Crabtree questioned whether Boluarte will be able to cling to power until the end of her term in office in 2026, describing the situation as “unsustainable”. However, a credible alternative is not obvious, with a plethora of 30 different parties, described by him as mainly “personalist vehicles created by politicians with their own agendas”.

Next was guest speaker Carlos Monge, an anthropologist and historian associated with the Peruvian development centre DESCO, the agrarian research body SEPIA and Publish What you Pay. From a ‘justice’ perspective, he tackled the topic of global heating, its impact on a highly vulnerable Peru, and the necessary energy transition away from fossil fuels.

“Those who contaminate more should pay more” he said, dismissing the COP process as dysfunctional and taken over by industry lobbyists. An energy transition is taking place, he said, but it is “too slow and unjust”. For those suffering from lack of access to energy (or energy poverty) the idea of ‘transition’ means nothing.

The energy transition is being shaped by an alliance of corporations and governments, Monge commented. It is a “new field for capital accumulation” in which common goods such as wind or sun are commodified, and people end up paying for it. He lamented the lack of a policy or overall strategy for people to generate their own renewable energy.

Daniela Soberón, an environmental lawyer from Lima’s Pacific University, who advises Amnesty International Peru on the human rights impact of global heating, spoke about the country’s heavy commitment to oil and gas and the way in which rural communities are often excluded from national energy planning.

“Peru’s energy transition needs to be more than just technical” she said, “but also social to deal with long-term inequalities”. She pointed to the rising global demand for critical minerals, of which Peru is a major producer but at a high cost in terms of local environmental degradation, human rights and social conflict. “If an energy transition is to be just it needs to be more than moving from one form of extraction to another” she commented.

Soberón also highlighted the way in which women are disproportionately affected by the climate crisis. For example, women are those most likely to be searching ever-scarce water and firewood.

Both she and Monge pointed to the importance of detecting and mapping examples of good initiatives by local governments or communities to generate energy as a common good and to identify who within the political elite might have a serious interest in the issue. “We need a political commitment at higher levels” said Monge, citing Colombia and Chile as countries with more progressive approaches.

Carlos Rivera, the director of IDL (Instituto de Defensa Legal) in Lima, addressed the growing problem of insecurity and organised crime in Peru. Theft, extortion and homicide are on the increase, the past year being the most violent for at least 20 years, he said. There have been major strikes by transport workers frustrated by lack of action on extortion, which has become so widespread that police estimate 50% of shops have been targeted, he affirmed, and even schools and colleges are affected. Much violent crime, Rivera said, intersects with politics, and he alleged a strong link between Congress and organised crime networks, saying “illegal economies have political representation in Congress”.

He identified three illegal sectors, in order of importance, with links to official politics: illegal gold mining; drug (coca) trafficking; and deforestation. “Congress has started to legislate in favour of criminal groups” he said. At a regional level too, representatives of illegal activities have been gaining power, he claimed. Rivera concluded that the country is “out of control”, that the police lack interest in tackling crime or are complicit with it, and that the economy is awash with dirty money.

In the final session of the day, Jhonatan Clausen from PUCP (Lima’s Catholic University) talked about the rise in poverty in Peru. Recent figures show 29% of Peruvians to be living below the poverty level nationwide, he said, almost as high a figure as during the pandemic. In rural areas poverty rises to 70%, he claimed with highland areas such as Huancavelica and Cajamarca worst affected, and coastal regions generally better off.

Clausen outlined three measures for assessing poverty: monetary, non-monetary multi-dimensional, and subjective. He agreed that there was still research to do on disaggregating data to take account of gender, race, and LGBT+. He stressed that there is work to do on environmental poverty too. He concluded that “poverty is still a significant pressing social issue and that far from the country having achieved goals of poverty reduction, poverty has increased”.

Though tackling seemingly disparate topics, there were several common threads that emerged during the day. Formal, informal and illegal mining came up repeatedly, though identifying and separating the three dimensions remained contentious. One thread that came through loud and clear was the absence of good governance in today’s Peru.