This week the national Ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo), together with the Congress and Auditor General, is holding a national meeting of indigenous peoples. It is doing so in coordination with a hitherto obscure indigenous group and without inviting either of the two national Amazonian indigenous organisations AIDESEP and CONAP.

This is seen by many as a replay of the (unsuccessful) attempt by the García government after the so-called ‘Baguazo’ in 2009 to divide the indigenous movement and promote an organisation parallel to AIDESEP.

Over the last fifty years, AIDESEP has grown to be the largest and most representative organisation of Peru’s Amazon indigenous while CONAP, a much smaller, less representative and less visible breakaway organisation, has persisted since 1987

Since its creation in 1993, the Defensoría has proved to be a consistent and independent defender of human rights and a loyal ally of indigenous peoples and their organisations. Until now, that is. Successive ombudsmen and their staff helped build one of the most solid and autonomous institutions in a public sector notorious for its weak institutions.

Since the appointment of Josué Gutiérrez as Defensor in May 2023 in a process criticised for its lack of transparency or regard for merit, the institution has been characterised by its ambiguity and tendency to sway with the political winds.

In recent months, Gutiérrez and his representative in Loreto region have appeared in the media accompanying the leadership of the National Organisation of Special Justice of the Indigenous Native and Peasant Peoples (ONAJEPINC for its initials in Spanish), also called Indigenous Justice. This is a little-known Loreto-based indigenous organisation founded in 2015.

The leadership of this organisation has been accused of charging community members for services not rendered and for land trafficking. It has also been criticised for consorting with the Coordinator for the Development of Loreto, a group of regional businessmen and functionaries who defend logging, deny the existence of indigenous people in voluntary isolation, and advocate for the elimination of indigenous reserves.

Indigenous Justice also questions the existence of indigenous people in voluntary isolation and the need for indigenous reserves to protect them. It supports the amendments made to the Forestry and Wildlife legislation that encourage deforestation. It is opposed to the Escazú Agreement.

This positioning puts it at loggerheads with AIDESEP whose agenda includes the protection of people in voluntary isolation, the questioning of forestry legislation, opposition to palm oil monoculture, and the protection of both environmental defenders and indigenous territories.

Gutiérrez has been promoting the organisation of this week’s national indigenous ‘summit’, which is taking place without the involvement of the existing representative indigenous organisations. The exception has been Indigenous Justice which has been encouraging local community leaders to attend.

Gutiérrez has denied any relationship between the Defensoría and Indigenous Justice. However, there are notable similarities in their agendas. Gutiérrez has declared that the issue of indigenous people in voluntary isolation is not on his agenda. He has also refused to explain why a national congress is being organised without reference to existing representative organisations and including only community leaders. The criteria used for inviting participants remains unclear.

For their part, AIDESEP and CONAP, along with regional organisations such as ORPIO in Loreto and ORAU in Ucayali, have questioned the whole process and are accusing Gutiérrez of trying to divide the indigenous movement and legitimise Indigenous Justice. This is what the García government sought to do in 2009.

We will have a clearer idea after the dust from the ‘summit’ settles whether this strategy proves unsuccessful or whether, alternatively, we are on the cusp of a period of division and discord within the movement and one of conflict between the Defensoría and its erstwhile allies.