Josué Gutiérrez, the ombudsman (Defensor del Pueblo), has argued that the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) is mistaken in its damning assessment of the way in which he, Gutiérrez, went about the appointment of a special commission to select new members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ). Both the IACHR and the International Observer Mission concluded that the special commission was chosen using procedures that were far removed from internationally accepted standards of transparency.
In a session on 15 November, the IACHR analysed the shortcomings in the procedures adopted, supported in its assessment by both the conclusions of the International Observer Mission and Peru’s Instituto de Defensa Legal.
In its 52-page report, the Mission claimed that “the process for selecting the JNJ was carried out without fulfilling the most minimal standards of transparency, publicity, citizen oversight, openness to scrutiny, technical criteria in producing proof of knowledge, and equality of conditions for those who took part”. It was also highly critical of the way in which a single university, ESAN, was selected to come up with questions to test candidates’ knowledge of the legal terrain.
As we have mentioned many times, the JNJ has been the target of repeated attack by far-right parties in Congress. It is the body responsible for appointing and dismissing both judges and public prosecutors. It also selects the heads of two of the three electoral bodies, the ONPE and the Reniec. The new members of the JNJ were sworn in on 30 October and take up their responsibilities in January. A number of those appointed have been seen as people with doubtful backgrounds.
Gutiérrez was appointed by the Congress as Defensor del Pueblo in 2023. His selection was also criticised for lacking in transparency and for the selection of someone with little experience in defending human and citizen rights.
Recent Comments