Rafael López Aliaga, the candidate for the far-right Renovación Popular (RP) party leads his main rival Francis Allison from Avanza País, another right-wing party, in his battle to win control of the Lima mayoralty for the next four years. However, as elsewhere, the final result may depend on how contested ballot returns are processed by the electoral authorities. The result in Lima may also depend on whether the authorities validate López Aliaga’s ploy to return as mayor having occupied the position for the last four years despite a constitutional ban on immediate re-election.

The electoral law sets out procedures for the resolution of disputed ballots. These may delay the announcement of results for several weeks, especially when the voting tallies are close. In the case of Lima, with 92.9% of the votes validated, López Aliaga had 27.7% of the vote to Allison’s 26.9%, a difference of roughly 45,000 votes. In the gubernatorial elections for regions outside Lima, there were also a number of close results. In these, there has to be a second round, scheduled for 29 October, where no one candidate exceeds 30% of the total valid vote.

As we went to press, the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE) had yet to make a decision with respect to López Aliaga’s attempts to return to the Lima mayoralty while the constitution forbids immediate re-election. Initially Luis Rubio stood as mayoral candidate for RP, but he withdrew before the election citing ‘personal reasons. López Aliaga stood for the post of primer regidor, a post that replaces the mayor when the mayoralty becomes vacant.

This dodge to avoid the ban on re-election has been employed by several other candidates in the recent elections. The JNE has been widely criticised for not ruling out López Aliaga’s manoeuvre. It will have to decide, once the count is complete, whether to authorise it.

One of the surprises in the Lima elections was the strong vote for Allison. Opinion polls for most of the campaign suggested that Carlos Bruce, the candidate for Somos Perú, was López Aliaga’s main rival. He came a fairly distant third with around 15% of the vote. López Aliaga, the most populist of the three, narrowly failed to beat Roberto Sánchez, the left-wing candidate of Juntos por el Perú (JPP), to win a place in the second round of presidential elections.

Elsewhere in Peru, voters elected regional governors as well as provincial and district mayors. The results of these were a mixed bag, with parties that had done poorly in the presidential and legislative election in April, doing surprisingly well. They included Somos Perú and the Alianza para el Progreso.

Parties that did well in the national elections fared poorly. Chief among these was Fuerza Popular (FP), the right-wing party of Keiko Fujimori, which failed to win a single gubernatorial contest. This was also the case of JPP, the Partido de Buen Gobierno and Obras, parties that came second, fourth and fifth in the first round of presidential elections. None of these parties, which lack local organisation, put much energy into campaigning for the subnational elections.

Apart from Lima, where the final result remains in doubt, RP only won the governorship elections in Callao.

On the left, Verónika Mendoza appears to have won the gubernatorial election in Cuzco, but not for the JPP the party for which she stood as presidential candidate (coming third) in 2016. Ahora Nación, the left-of-centre party founded by Alfonso López Chau for the presidential elections, picked up several governorships in the south of the country.

The results therefore show, once again, the lack of support for FP in much of Peru. This may complicate governance by the ruling party, especially with its lack of a majority in both houses of Congress. It remains to be seen whether, if he takes over in Lima, López Aliaga will prove to be a thorn in Keiko Fujimor’s flesh. However, sub-national governments, will continue to depend on central government for the bulk of their finance.

More of a problem may be in the extent to which the new sub-regional authorities, which will take over on 1 January, are in hock to organised criminal activities.