For years Peru’s approach to artisanal and small-scale mining has revolved around one central question: how can miners operating outside the formal system be brought into compliance? After repeated extensions, new procedures and limited results, Energy and Mines Minister Guillermo Shinno has now signaled a possible different approach: what kind of regulatory system is appropriate for an economic activity operating at a radically different scale from large-scale mining?
The question arises from some striking numbers. Shinno told Congress this week that some 31,500 miners are registered in the REINFO (Registro Integral de Formalización Minera), while only about 2,300 have completed formalisation. Meanwhile, some 25,000 environmental instruments, known as IGAFOMs, submitted by REINFO holders are still awaiting evaluation. His conclusion was stark: as currently conceived, the process is not working.
Shinno says the government intends to submit a new ASM (Artisanal and Small-scale Mining) Law to Congress by 15 October. The proposal appears to go beyond replacing or extending the existing system. His diagnosis is that artisanal and small-scale miners are being asked to meet requirements designed for operations of a very different scale. If so, it is the regulatory framework itself that needs to change.
What Shinno is proposing is a simpler regime, with requirements adapted to the scale and characteristics of artisanal and small-scale mining. He has been careful to say that this should not mean weaker safety standards. The issue is not simply whether there should be fewer requirements, but whether they make sense and can realistically be complied with, evaluated and enforced.
This takes the discussion beyond compliance and towards institutional resilience. The question is no longer only why so many miners have failed to meet the requirements, but whether the rules and institutions governing them have kept pace as the activity itself has changed. The backlog of environmental assessments suggests that they have not. The challenge is not simply to devise better rules for present conditions, but to build institutions capable of adapting as those conditions change.
Traceability offers a practical example. Shinno has indicated that greater attention should be given to the firms that purchase and process mineral, with the state playing a role in verifying its origin. Artisanal production is dispersed across thousands of operations. But as mineral moves through the supply chain, much of it passes through a far smaller number of processing plants. These thus become important points for establishing where mineral comes from and where it goes in a supply chain that is otherwise opaque and dispersed.
There is an important distinction here. Bringing miners into the formal system and combating illegal mining are related, but they are not the same problem. Illegal mining requires enforcement and raises wider questions about criminal networks, illicit supply chains and territorial control that need to be considered separately. Making the system more achievable for small-scale producers does not mean being more permissive towards illegal mining. More realistic requirements, together with better traceability, should in fact make it easier to identify those operating outside the law.
There are good reasons for caution. The ASM bill has not yet been published, and much will depend on what it contains and the regulations that follow. But changing the rules will not be enough. The larger challenge is whether the institutions that apply them can learn, coordinate and change as the activity they regulate changes. Otherwise, a system designed to solve today’s problems may simply create a new set of rigidities tomorrow.
Artisanal and small-scale mining itself will not stand still. It is part of a mining sector, an economy and a society that are also changing. Technologies will change, as will mineral demand, supply chains, territories and the pressures created by the energy transition. The question is not simply what rules Peru needs for the ASM we see today. It is what kind of institutions will be needed to govern an activity whose place in the economy and society will continue to evolve.
Shinno’s recent statement is thus encouraging. It suggests a willingness to stop asking only how miners can be made to fit a system that has produced very limited results, and to begin asking whether the system itself needs to change. We have yet to see how far the new law will take up that idea. But it opens up a more important question: not simply how to fix the current process, but what kind of mining governance Peru needs to build for what comes next.
Recent Comments