Peru’s Amazonian indigenous peoples have been subject to constant and repeated attacks in recent years, not only from illegal actors – such as loggers, gold miners, and drug and human traffickers – but also national and regional authorities, the judiciary and, especially, the national Congress. Nevertheless, recent actions by the Inter-American Human Rights Commission (IACHR), a constitutional court in Lima, and newly-appointed President José Jerí may indicate growing attention to indigenous concerns.
The IACHR warned in a recent report that human rights defenders in the Americas face threats, criminalisation and violence. It argues that defending territory and the environment as well as demanding justice continue to be high-risk activities, observing that in Peru 58 persons have died simply between 2012 and 2023 for defending their territory and nature. Furthermore, indigenous peoples are especially vulnerable because of the intersection between their identity and their activism.
The Commission highlights the reduction in civic space and the increase in legal measures that restrict the scope of action of civil society organisations, as illustrated by modifications to the APCI Law in Peru that impose greater controls and limit access to funding. It also justifies its calls for the protection of indigenous human and environmental defenders by pointing out that the death of an indigenous leader has a profound collective impact because it affects community cohesion and weakens processes of territorial defence.
Finally, the IACHR urges member states to adopt public policies that guarantee the protection of human rights defenders; offer effective protection to those in a situation of risk; investigate the crimes against these persons and sanction those found responsible; stop criminalisation; and eliminate penal and legislative measures that violate principles of legality.
In an unprecedented judicial decision, the Lima’s Fourth Constitutional Court declared the failure of the Peruvian state to approve and execute policies for titling the territories of indigenous communities to be a violation of the constitution. The sentence was directed at the prime minister, various ministries, and the San Martín, Loreto, Amazonas and Madre de Dios regional governments.
This is the first decision of this kind and, by recognising that state inaction constitutes a systematic violation of rights, it represents a milestone in the fight by indigenous peoples for legal security. The decision was in response to a lawsuit presented by Aidesep, the national Amazonian indigenous organisation, and three local federations.
Without property titles communities are defenceless in the face of invasions by colonists, loggers, drug traffickers and other illegal actors. The sentence recognises that land tenure insecurity is one of the structural causes of the violence suffered by indigenous peoples and the assassinations of their leaders and defenders.
The court described as “alarming” the fact that some 600 communities are still awaiting titles to their territories. The sentence also includes a key protection order for indigenous people in voluntary isolation. The court reaffirms that the state is prohibited from granting concessions in existing reserves for indigenous in voluntary isolation or in reserves awaiting official recognition and approval. It also prohibits regional governments from granting forestry or wildlife concessions in these reserves.
By declaring state inaction as unconstitutional the judiciary has recognised a historic debt owed to the country’s indigenous peoples.
On 19 October, President José Jerí met in the governmental palace with representatives of indigenous communities from the Huánuco, Loreto and Ucayali regions to signal the executive’s commitment to strengthen dialogue with indigenous communities and respond to their principal demands, prioritising actions in security, infrastructure and political participation.
The indigenous leaders requested the creation of a Permanent National Dialogue Commission led by the Prime Minister’s Office and the approval of indigenous communal security mechanisms. For his part, Jerí offered to work with regional governments to improve land and air connections to the most remote communities in order to promote local economic development and strengthen the presence of the state.
The indigenous organisations that participated in the meeting now plan to wait and see if there will be concrete results in areas such as infrastructure, security and political representation.
Recent Comments