The Dutch National Contact Point (NCP) of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) has issued a report concluding that the Argentine oil company Pluspetrol violated the rights of indigenous communities and was responsible for environmental contamination during its operations in Block 1AB (now called Block 192) in the Loreto region between 2000 and 2015. It urges Pluspetrol to remedy all the damages caused by its extractive activities in the region.

The NCP’s decision is not legally binding but sets a global precedent because it is the first time that the Dutch NCP has held a so-called ‘letter box’ company responsible for environmental and human rights violations. Although Pluspetrol is an Argentine-based corporation, its legal headquarters are in The Netherlands.

The decision is in response to a formal complaint presented in March 2020 by a representative of four indigenous federations impacted by Pluspetrol’s operations. They received technical support from four NGOs: Somo, Oxfam Novib, Perú Equidad and Oxfam’s office in Peru. The complaint was admitted by the NCP in 2021 and this was the first time that a complaint against a ‘letter box’ company had been admitted by an NCP of the OECD.

During the investigation, the NCP invited Pluspetrol to take part in dialogue and mediation. The company, however, refused to do so, a move deemed contrary to the principles of responsible corporate behaviour promoted by the OECD.

According to the complaint ratified by the NCP, from 2000 to 2015 Pluspetrol failed to comply with the directives established by the OECD regarding environmental protection, indigenous rights, health, tax payments and transparency.

According to the Fund for the Promotion of Natural Protected Areas in Peru (Profonampe), the company left behind 3,249 impacted sites whose rehabilitation will cost approximately US$1.5 billion.

The NCP determined that Pluspetrol did not take measures to prevent the environmental impacts resulting from its operations that affected the health of indigenous people. It also claimed Pluspetrol signed agreements with “potentially prejudicial clauses” in regard to the indigenous communities. The company thus failed to establish a relationship of trust with the communities.

In 2021, after six years of negotiations during which successive company abandonment plans were received and its observations deemed unsatisfactory, the environmental authorities declared the company to be non-compliant.

The company thus took advantage of a weak and negligent state to evade its obligations and then abandoned the Block, leaving behind only US$5 million dollars (estimated to cover only 0.3% of the total cost) for remediation.

This responsibility will now be assumed by the state which has established a technical group led by the Ministry of Energy and Mines to prepare an action plan within four months to reactivate health, drinking water, educational and rural electrification projects in Block 192 that are paralysed or delayed.

This represents a sorry tale of corporate irresponsibility and state negligence, resulting in the impunity of those responsible.