Economists have sharply criticised a proposal mooted in Congress to change the distribution of tax receipts from sales tax (IGV) to the benefit of local administrations at the expense of the national Treasury. They claim that this would not only further increase the fiscal deficit (in an election year) but would simply augment the cash available to local governments which, repeatedly, have proved unable to spend in ways that promote development.
Currently, IGV stands at 18% of the value of goods and services. Of this, currently 2% goes to subnational governments (regions, provinces and districts) and 16% goes to the national government. Under the proposal supported by the Finance Commission in Congress, 4% would go to subnational government, reducing Treasury receipts to 14%.
Luis Miguel Castilla, a former technocratic finance minister, has loudly criticised the new minister, Raúl Pérez Reyes, succumbing to congressional pressures and for maintaining that this measure would not impact the deficit. “Never have we seen a minister shoot himself in the foot in such a short time” he is quoted as saying. He went on to say that the Boluarte government is using fiscal policy “to buy support” in Congress. He even went so far as to say that economic management by the Ministry of Economy and Finance was more technically competent during the Castillo government than at present.
As if to emphasize the point, this week, Congress approved a law (on the first round of voting) that would give tax benefits to large agricultural exporters in a bill promoted by Fuerza Popular. The measure, which is estimated to cost the Treasury around 200 million soles this year, was criticised by centre-left parliamentarians and by unions. According to the CGTP, 95% of employment by large-scale enterprises is governed by temporary work contracts that severely reduce social benefits to workers.
According to figures from the Central Bank, Treasury income in 2024 was barely 14% of GDP, one of the lowest rates in Latin America, while the fiscal deficit reached 3.5% of GDP.
Recent Comments