The UN Special Rapporteur on the Independence of Judges and Lawyers, Margaret Satterthwaite, has issued a strong attack on various legislative initiatives designed to curb the autonomy of the judiciary in Peru. She sees these as “concentrating excessive power in the Congress”. For its part, the government has denied her claims, saying “we reject any such affirmation that places in doubt the strength of our democratic system and respect for the separation of powers”.

On 2 November, Satterthwaite expressed her concern about the prospect of removing members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ) by the Peruvian Congress, arguing that the JNJ was essential to ensuring judicial independence. She noted the accusations made in a congressional sub-committee that sought the suspension of JNJ members.

Then, in a letter to the Boluarte government dated 19 November, she cited a string of legal changes introduced in the recent past designed to undermine the judicial power and other judicial entities. Responding in a note dated 21 November, Peru’s permanent representative to the UN wrote that the reforms introduced had been the subject of wide consultation with entities whose opinions had been sought by Congress, going on to reaffirm “our commitment to (…) strengthening democratic institutionality and respect for and guarantee of human rights”.

Commenting on this reply, Satterthwaite wrote on her official X account that “I am deeply concerned about the recent proposals for legal reforms in Peru that could undermine judicial independence in contradiction to international obligations in the area of human rights”.