Draft legislation that would limit the application of rulings in Peru by the Inter-American Human Rights Court (IAHRC) has been approved by the Constitutional Commission and scheduled for debate by Congress.

Draft law No. 6290/2023-CR was presented by Congressman Alejandro Muñante from the Renovación Popular group and approved by the Constitutional Commission and has now been scheduled for debate by the full Congress.

The bill proposes that only sentences emitted by the IAHRC which have resulted from cases directly involving Peru should be applicable within the country. Hitherto, jurisprudence from all cases decided by the Court have been considered applicable in all 34 countries that comprise the Organization of American States (OAS) under a ruling equivalent to precedent.

The IAHRC is a Latin America-wide appeals court under the treaty establishing the OAS. As such, it is empowered to consider and, if necessary, overrule decisions by national courts that affect human rights, thus establishing a region-wide jurisprudence. This proposal is the latest in a series of proposals aimed at limiting international monitoring and control of human rights abuses committed or tolerated by national institutions.

In practice, if passed, this legislation would seriously limit the rights of indigenous peoples because many of the IAHRC’s decisions have established standards for the protection of rights of indigenous peoples throughout the region, arising from cases in which the Peruvian state did not participate. It could leave indigenous peoples vulnerable to the illegal exploitation of their territories, the violation of their traditional rights, and could limit their access to justice.

The proposal has been rejected in pronouncements by the national Amazonian indigenous organisation AIDESEP and by the Autonomous Territorial Government of the Wampis Nation. The United Nations rapporteur for the protection of the rights of indigenous peoples has declared that the bill “represents a serous reversal in the protection of the rights of indigenous peoples and places their lands, resources and culture at risk”.