On 9 October, with 70 votes in favour, Congress approved a law that modifies the procedures for judging disputes over the competences of the judiciary, further extending the powers of the legislature. An opponent of the law, Susel Paredes, labelled it a constitutional “coup d’etat”. For his part, the author of the legislation, Fernando Rospigliosi, said that it would avoid “politicised magistrates” blocking congressional decisions. Final approval will require a further vote.
Meanwhile, on the same day as its publication in El Peruano (the official gazette), President Dina Boluarte promulgated legislation (Law 32130) that transfers responsibility for preliminary investigations to the police force from the public prosecution service. It also demands the presence of a lawyer in the event of a raid on suspects. The bill has been criticised for undermining the constitutional role allotted to the public prosecution service and awarding to the police force functions that it is ill prepared to assume. It is also seen as enabling the criminalisation of protest.
With the majority in Congress refusing to repeal Law 32108, widely seen as promoting organised crime in Peru, the legislature is pushing ahead with its own agenda to win control over the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ), a lynchpin that serves to protect the independence of the judiciary. In particular, it seeks to reduce the number of votes in the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) necessary for evicting members of the JNJ.
The move stems from an initiative by Fernando Rospigliosi, the president of the Constitutional Commission in Congress and a foremost member of the far-right party, Fuerza Popular, led by Keiko Fujimori. His initiative reduces from five to four the votes required to resolve clashes of competence between the Congress and the judiciary and introduces restrictions whereby decisions taken in Congress can be challenged by the judiciary.
As readers will be aware, the right-wing majority in Congress has long been seeking to clip the wings of the judicial power, especially those of the JNJ, the entity responsible for appointing and dismissing both judges and public prosecutors. The JNJ also plays a central role in appointments to the electoral authorities.
Two members of the JNJ have been in the firing line: Inés Tello and Aldo Vásquez. The judicial branch upheld appeals (medidas cautelares) by both against measures to sack them as JNJ members. They were consequently reinstated. The Congress argued that the judiciary had exceeded its competences in this matter, appealing to the TC.
Judicial opinion (see PSG article for instance) argues that this legislation fundamentally alters the balance of power in favour of the Congress, reinforcing its ability to use constitutional accusations against those seen to oppose its interests. It will restrict the scope for appeals by those affected. There are several senior officials potentially in the firing line, including the president of the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE) who is blamed by the Fujimorista camp for his role in legitimising the 2021 presidential election in which Keiko Fujimori narrowly lost to Pedro Castillo.
Another target has been Zoraida Avalos, the senior prosecutor, who was constitutionally accused but who managed to prove that her removal had been arbitrary. She was accused of failing to have investigated Castillo.
The new law would also make it impossible to challenge in the judiciary the way in which Congress selects TC magistrates, the ombudsman, the comptroller-general and other key posts. Procedures for electing both the TC and ombudsman were the subject of widespread criticism for their lack of transparency.
In a further move designed to clip the wings of the judiciary, Congress passed (on a preliminary vote) on 11 October a law that would punish judges that impose detentions that are then revoked by a higher court. Prosecutors that seek to impose such detentions can also be punished. Sigrid Bazán, an opposition member, described this as being “clearly unconstitutional”. The law was sponsored by Renovación Popular and Avanza País.
Recent Comments