The balance of constitutional power between the executive and the judiciary may have shifted as a consequence of the final approval by Congress of a law that puts the responsibility for opening criminal investigations into the hands of the police (PNP). Unlike the public prosecution service, the PNP comes under the jurisdiction of the Ministry of the Interior.

The vote in Congress was approved by 80 in favour, six against and 31 abstentions. Those voting in favour included members from Fuerza Popular, Perú Libre and Renovación Popular, amongst others. It was the second such vote. Two weeks earlier, the legislation had been approved on a first vote, despite objections from centre-left members of Congress, some of whom argued that it violated the constitution (Article 159) and would assist in the criminalisation of protest.

As readers will be aware, conservative members of Congress have been engaged in a persistent struggle to bring the public prosecution service under their control through changes to the system by which prosecutors are selected. This is the role of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ). Several legislators have had accusations of corruption levelled against them.

The chief public prosecutor, Juan Carlos Villena, who has been the target for attack in Congress, argued that the police lacked both the resources and training to carry out the role of conducting preliminary investigations. He reiterated the unconstitutionality of the move and that the police lacked the necessary objectivity to conduct investigations.

A process of new appointments to the seven-member JNJ is underway, an exercise described by the head of an international observer mission as “lacking any sort of transparency”. According to Stephen McFarland, the Ombudsman, Josué Gutiérrez, who heads up the selection team, refused to be interviewed by the mission. According to a study by Ojo Público, a substantial number of the 23 candidates now short-listed have connections to known criminal organisations and to right-wing political parties. For a graphic take by Carlín on the war on the Ministerio Público, see here.