In a joint letter to the Inter-American Court on Human Rights on 8 July, President Dina Boluarte and Alejandro Soto, the president of Congress, rejected the ruling of the Court that demanded that Peru reconsider the so-called Amnesty Law. This offers effective amnesty to all those accused of crimes against humanity prior to 2002, the date on which Peru signed up to the Statute of Rome. They emphasised Peru’s sovereign right to legislate on the matter.

In the letter, the two authorities wrote that the Court’s ruling “sought to constitute itself within our state as a super-power capable of directing and ordering the way in which the legitimate organs should operate”. Previously, Prime Minister Gustavo Adrianzén had said that he was “indignant” at the ruling adopted by the Court.

Boluarte has yet to indicate whether she intends to promulgate the legislation approved on a second reading by the Permanent Commission with little proper discussion. She has the option to promulgate it, reject it, or leave 30 days for the Congress to promulgate the law itself.

Lawyers have questioned the legality of Boluarte’s and Soto’s communication, claiming that it violates established channels for communicating with the Court. According to Pedro Cateriano, a lawyer and former prime minister, the letter had not even been written on official headed paper. Also, while signed by the presidents of two powers, it had not been signed by the president of the judiciary.

While Boluarte claims that it was not the government’s intention to break with the Inter-American system on human rights, there are strong voices within Fuerza Popular and other parties that this is precisely what Peru should do. One concern likely to limit the executive’s appetite for a breach with the system is its desire to be accepted as a full member by the OECD.

As well as the Amnesty Law, Ojo Público has identified a further 26 pieces of legislation passed between 2021 and now which have the effect of subverting Peru’s democratic institutions, as well as five others pending promulgation. Most have been congressional initiatives, but with the executive doing little to act as a counterbalance.