The ill-advised comment of President Dina Boluarte that Puno is not Peru has added hurt to injury here in the Altiplano. Boluarte has so far studiously avoided any hint of apology for the killing of at least 29 punenos just over a year ago, principally in Juliaca, Ilave and Macusani. Although she is the subject of a judicial investigation into the killings, there is also zero chance of her being brought to book – at least so long as she remains in office.
People in Puno remain deeply resentful of the way the authorities from distant Lima appear to discredit the suffering of their loved ones. As well as those who lost their lives, many hundreds were wounded in assaults by the police and the military in January 2023. “We shall never know the numbers involved” says Patrcia Ryan, a Maryknoll sister who has worked in Puno since 1972, “People were reluctant to go to hospitals with their wounds for fear of being branded ‘terrorists’” Even a year later she says that the atmosphere is one of fear, albeit also one of defiance.
Pointedly, people in Puno denied the president an invitation to attend the festival of La Candelaria in mid-February, one of the high points of Peru’s folkloric calendar. The minister of culture who did attend was persuaded at the last minute to leave and return to Lima.
Public opinion in Lima, with notable exceptions, shows little understanding of these feelings of grievance. Puno tends to be regarded as a far-off part of the country full of indigenous troublemakers. Those who took to the streets last year were branded as ‘terrorists’ intent on creating violence. “This was the opposite of the truth” says Ryan, who stresses the peaceful intentions of the protestors.
Some opinion formers in Lima even seem to consider the region as prey to expansionism by neighbouring Bolivia. Contrary to what Boluarte asserted, people in Puno feel very much part of Peru, while maintaining connections with people the other side of the border, based, in part, on ethnic identity and commercial interaction.
The feelings of resentment towards the Boluarte administration have indeed acted as a catalyst for bringing together the people of Puno together, the Aymara people who predominate in the south of the region and the Quechuas of the north. Juliaca, indeed, one of Peru’s fastest growing cities where people voted massively for deposed president and former rural schoolteacher Pedro Castillo in the 2021 elections, is a sort of melting pot of Puno’s different ethnic identities.
The region’s woes over recent years have been multiple. Like other parts of Peru, the region suffered enormous damage because of the Covid-19 pandemic which exposed the weakness of the country’s public health infrastructure. The local hospital system was overwhelmed, and the death rate was high. People with other health problems were displaced from the hospital system. Not only did the pandemic bring a massive contraction in economic activity but, in a region highly dependent on tourism, it led to complete shutdown in activity for the best part of two years.
Then, on top of the pandemic, the region’s economy was hit once more by the protests that followed the killings in Juliaca and elsewhere at the beginning of 2023. Roads were blocked for weeks on end in response to the repressive actions of the police and military. Commerce, industry and agriculture were badly hit, not to mention tourist flows which had just begun to recover from the pandemic.
More recently, during much of 2023, the region has faced a crippling drought brought on by a combination of the El Nino phenomenon and climate change. This has wrought havoc among the region’s peasant farmers, already among the poorest of the poor in Peru. Crops failed and farmers were forced to sell off their livestock at rock-bottom prices. Farmers lacked seed to plant for the following year. The coastline of Lake Titicaca dried up exposing huge expanses of dried mud and with it the wells on which surrounding communities depend for their water.
The role of climate change is now being felt across the Altiplano, both in Puno and in Bolivia. Although seasonal rains have finally come, they have arrived late and with a ferocity that has caused flooding and crops to be washed away. Also, the region is feeling the brunt of the effects of climate change through the melting of glaciers which have traditionally provided an important source of water, especially for people living in the higher rural areas.
Problems of climate change are accompanied by the impact of mining on communities. Many of the watersheds in Puno and Lake Titicaca itself reveal chronic problems of contamination, the result of the use of mercury to purify gold. Indices of mercury and arsenic in the blood of both rural populations and town dwellers are reportedly high. But there is limited access to the sort of blood testing facilities required to prove the scale of the problem.
To these issues, the government in far-off Lima seems largely unresponsive. Local farmers complain that they receive little or no help in trying the mitigate the impact of climate change, while credits go mainly to large landowners elsewhere producing cash crops for export. Mining concessions are awarded with no consultation with local people. However, Ryan underlines some positive factors as well as negative ones. “The people have gained in consciousness of their rights”, she says, “despite the repression and the climate of fear, both men and women are prepared to defend themselves when they see their rights ignored, and they will not forget the deaths that have occurred”.
Recent Comments