This week, Justice Minister Eduardo Arana paid a visit to El Salvador with a view to it providing a model for Peru’s penitentiary system. At a press conference, Prime Minister Alberto Otárola said that he considered that the Bukele administration had constructed “an infrastructure that was suitable, modern and efficient, apt for the most violent and dangerous prisoners”. He said that Arana had held meetings with justice officials in San Salvador about “the viability of such prisons that we hopefully think of implementing in Peru”.
El Salvador’s justice system has been roundly criticised internationally for failing to heed basic human rights standards. Large numbers of people have been rounded up for supposedly belonging to gangs. In her Independence Day speech, Boluarte promised a crackdown on criminality in Peru. In El Salvador, where President Nayib Bukele was unconstitutionally re-elected earlier this month, the president’s policies have found favour with an electorate beleaguered by gang violence.
Otárola justified the building of Salvadoran-style prisons as the answer to chronic overcrowding in most existing jails.
This in a week when the president of Congress, Alejandro Soto, advocated the rebuilding of Peru’s notorious island prison at El Frontón. In the past this was home for some of Peru’s most illustrious opposition leaders. It was destroyed following an uprising by Sendero Luminoso inmates in 1986 during Alan García’s first term as president. Soto’s proposals have been widely discredited as impractical and uneconomic.
The Boluarte government will also probably be looking northwards to Ecuador where a clampdown on gang activity, now reclassified as ‘terrorism’, has led to mass arrests since the beginning of the year, but where these apparent ‘successes’ have brought the new president, Daniel Noboa, popularity benefits. The Ecuadorian government is also pursuing a massive expansion of prison capacity. In its weekly outreach, WOLA (the Washington Office on Latin America) explains why Ecuador – and ditto Peru – would do best not to heed the Bukele model.
Recent Comments