Far-right members of the Peruvian Congress have announced steps that would make the Inter-American System of Human Rights accept changes or face Peru’s possible withdrawal. This follows the critical report by the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights covering the killings that took place in southern Peru in December 2022 and January 2023. The Commission also criticised attempts to sack members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ).

The Inter-American System provides citizens of member states a final court of appeal when such appeals are turned down within national courts.

The Congress has set up a high-level commission to press the issue. In an interview in La República, Julissa Mantilla, a Peruvian former president of the Commission, argues that such posturing would have highly undesirable consequences. She argues that all states have the right to suggest reforms, but not in the way that Peruvian members of Congress want. Any reform would have to be discussed and approved by all other members and setting an arbitrary deadline was inappropriate.

She thinks this was just a deliberate ploy to justify withdrawal by presenting demands that cannot be met. Withdrawal, she adds, would not mean that ongoing complaints against Peru would be waived.

Further, she makes the point that Peru’s membership of the Inter-American Convention results from a formal treaty and that it is not – under the Peruvian constitution – a matter for the Congress. The 1993 constitution makes foreign policy a function of the executive, not the legislature. “I would have expected that the Foreign Ministry would have clarified this issue”, she says, “it surprises me that within the separation of powers [the ministry] has not taken a stand pointing out that it is the executive that takes this sort of decision”.

She goes on to make the point that the Commission’s report did not seek to qualify or condemn what had happened, simply to urge the public prosecutor’s office to investigate. While it remains a right for people to protest, this does not condone the use of violence, and while the use of violence “is a faculty of the state, it has to be proportionate”. She says that there is clear evidence of indiscriminate killing.

The investigation by the public prosecutor has, as we have previously made clear, proceeded at a snail’s pace.

Mantilla argues that if Peru were to withdraw from the Convention, it would deprive Peruvian citizens of a right to justice. “It implies less protection for the population”, he says. Such a move is pointing in the wrong direction. “There is an enormous gulf between Lima and the rest of the country (…) that will not be resolved by discourses that point towards forgetting; that always ends in impunity”.

The Inter-American Commission has also made its views known on the attempts by members of Congress to dismiss the seven members of the JNJ. According to Mantilla “the JNJ is a guarantor and has to be defended”. She sees this as part of “the erosion of democracy in Peru” which is impacting on the way in which Peru is viewed abroad.

Mantilla was dropped by Peru as its nominee for the Commission without explanation in April 2023.