The United Nations, the Organization of American States (OAS) and the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (IACHR) have together decried attempts by the Peruvian Congress to take steps that would lead to the dismissal of members of the Junta Nacional de Justicia (JNJ).
Their statements came in response to a volte-face by which a report recommending that no further steps should be taken against the seven-member JNJ was replaced at the last minute by one recommending precisely the opposite. An alliance of interests, led by the pro-Fujimori Fuerza Popular party, hastily rewrote the report’s conclusions.
The congressional commission in charge of the ‘summary’ investigation into supposed wrongdoing by the JNJ had submitted a report on 17 October in which they had concluded that, on the five charges against members of the JNJ, they had found nothing that could be construed as a “serious breach” (“causa grave”) in the accusations. This therefore opened the way for the charges to be dropped and for the current JNJ members to continue in office.
However, the very next day, the commission rewrote the conclusions of the report, saying that they charges were indeed “serious”, opening the way for the plenary of Congress to take the decision to force the resignation of the JNJ members and replace them with appointments more to their liking. This would require the backing of two-thirds of Congress, or 87 votes in favour.
This sudden about-turn was seen as a “coup in the making” in the opposition press. La República quotes a constitutional expert as saying “what was not a serious breach at lunchtime [on 18 October] became one by suppertime”.
Among the charges made against the JNJ was its supposed involvement in the case against the former chief public prosecutor, Zoraida Avalos. Party leaders in Congress believe that Avalos was less than persistent in following through on cases involving former president Pedro Castillo. The JNJ is also believed to have sought to influence the Supreme Court in the case against Avalos. It vehemently denies the charges.
As readers will be aware, the moves by Congress to dismiss the current members of the JNJ has been widely criticised, both within Peru and abroad, as further eroding democratic governance by not respecting the separation of powers. The JNJ has as its main function the appointment and dismissal of judges and public prosecutors.
It can also appoint and dismiss the leaders of Peru’s three electoral organisations. The heads of the Jurado Nacional de Elecciones (JNE) and the Oficina Nacional de Procesos Electorales (ONPE) have repeatedly been the target for criticism for their role in approving the results of the 2021 elections in which Pedro Castillo narrowly beat Keiko Fujimori to the finishing post. Political commentators contend that a JNE and/or ONPE whose leaders could be selected (albeit indirectly) by Congress cannot be construed as independent and would therefore place at risk the holding of free and fair elections.
Recent Comments