The death of six soldiers in the icy waters of the Ilave river in Puno last week raises serious questions both about the human rights of conscripts as well as the veracity of public statements about military actions.

The six soldiers concerned drowned in the Ilave river having been ordered to cross it by foot by their platoon leader, Captain Josué Frisancho. The incident took place on 6 March close to the town of Ilave, to the south of Puno near Lake Titicaca.

According to the statement issued by the Ministry of Defence, the soldiers were obliged to wade across the river on foot as they came under attack from members of the community who were hurling rocks and stones at them. General Jhonny León Rabanal, the military commander for operations in the south, is quoted as saying that the problem arose when locals obliged the patrol to cross the river as rocks rained down.

This version of events was placed in doubt by reporters who witnessed the scene in person and who claimed that members of communities were not in the immediate vicinity and that the platoon was not under attack. Far from harassing the soldiers, community members assisted in dragging the corpses of those who drowned (mostly Aymara-speaking conscripts from the immediate area) from the water and helping to resuscitate those that survived.

In subsequent interviews with the survivors it transpired that Frisancho had obliged the men to cross the river as a short-cut back to the barracks in Ilave, despite protestations that several did not know how to swim. One survivor related how they were weighed down by heavy equipment and that the water, swollen by rains in the mountains, was deeper and faster moving than usual.

Troops had been mobilised in the region when they faced strong protests against their presence, notably on 4 March in the nearby town of Juli. Seven people were wounded in confrontations there. Local people were demanding the withdrawal of the army presence from their communities in southern Puno.

A state of high tension has remained in Puno region since the killing of large numbers of demonstrators in the city of Juliaca in January. Investigations into the circumstances of these killings have yet to be released. As elsewhere, people in Puno are demanding the resignation of Dina Boluarte as president and the calling of immediate elections to both the presidency and Congress.

The incident at Ilavi has once again drawn public attention to the conditions that conscripts in the army, mostly indigenous people like those who died at Ilave, have to endure. As well as poor living conditions and frequent abuse by their superiors, conscripts receive meagre pay: between 256 and 365 soles a month (between £60 and £85 according to their status).

Since the events at Ilave, the La República reporter in Puno, Liubomir Fernández, claims to have received death threats for the articles published prominently in the newspaper.

In spite of the accounts of journalists, the Joint Command of the Armed Forces reiterated its version of events in a subsequent statement.