A month ago, this newsletter reported on a publication prepared by Stand.earth and the Amazon Network of Georeferenced Socio-Environmental Information (RAISG) for the Coordinator of Indigenous Organizations of the Amazonian Basin (COICA). This claimed that approximately 26% of the Amazonian rainforest has been deforested and that indigenous peoples have a key role to play in conserving the remaining 74%. The report further claimed that 86% of deforestation has taken place outside national protected areas and indigenous territories. Furthermore, the level of conservation of indigenous territories is comparable and even higher than that of protected areas.

A new report, prepared by the Monitoring of the Peruvian Amazon Project (MAAP), estimates that 13% of the original Amazon biome forest has been lost. However, focusing on just the eastern third of the Amazon biome, the report estimates that 31% of the original forest has been lost, above the speculated tipping point threshold (of between 20% and 25%). This finding is critical because the tipping point is likely to be triggered in the eastern Amazon, as it is closest to the oceanic source of the water that then flows to the central and western Amazon.

The MAAP report explains that the tipping point is where parts of the rainforest will convert into drier ecosystems, such as open canopy scrubland and savannah, due to disrupted precipitation patterns and more intense dry seasons, both exacerbated by deforestation. This is because the Amazon generates much of its own rainfall by recycling water as air passes from its major source in the Atlantic Ocean. Thus, high deforestation in the eastern Amazon may lead to impacts in the central and western Amazon.

The MAAP study comprises three parts. First, it presents the first known rigorous estimate of original Amazon biome forest prior to European colonization: over 647 million hectares (1.6 billion acres). Second, it estimates the accumulated total Amazon Forest loss, from the original estimate to the present: over 85 million hectares (211 million acres). Combining these two results, it then estimates that 13% of the original Amazon biome forest has been lost.

However, it is important to note that only 6.3% of the rainforest has been lost in the western Amazon, which is largely occupied by Peru, and this is below the tipping point. Thus, the MAAP report concludes: “the western Amazon near the Andes mountains would likely maintain its rainforests, as air currents flowing over the mountains would continue causing water vapor to condense and fall as rain.”

In an article by Yvette Sierra Praeli about the RAISG-Stand.earth report, the proposals to stop Amazon deforestation include the immediate recognition of the indigenous territories that have already been identified, as well as the allocation of resources to strengthen territorial management. It is also proposed that more than half of the Amazon should be under territorial management, so that the entire region can be preserved.

The report proposes the following solutions:

  • the titling of around 100 million hectares that are still in dispute;
  • the adoption of a forestry and zoning policy that would allow the creation of intangible areas, without roads and without extractive activities;
  • the restoration of degraded land;
  • the creation of Indigenous reservations or co-managed protected areas; and
  • an immediate moratorium on deforestation and industrial degradation of all primary forests.

This agenda represents a tall order for any government in the Amazon basin, even if Lula wins the second round of the presidential election in Brazil on 30 October.