Last week, the PSG listened to an online conference entitled ‘Transparency in the Extractive Industries in Latin America: an Exchange of Experiences in the EITI initiative’ organised by the Lima-based Derechos, Ambiente y Recursos Naturales (DAR), Grupo Propuesta Ciudadana, EITI-Perú and USAID.

The event sought to identify some of the advances in transparency and governance initiatives in Latin America and discuss the key challenges that countries are facing in implementing the Extractives Industry Transparency Initiative (EITI) standard.

Present were representatives from Colombia, Mexico, Argentina, and Peru. The EITI standard has been implemented longest in Peru, since 2012.

For the panellists, there were many things to celebrate, including the expansion in the scope of the EITI. This originally only concentrated on ensuring that extractive companies published all payments to host countries and that governments made public how this money would be invested. Nowadays, there are broader commitments, including the publication of contracts and environmental expectations. In Peru, the data are out there; the big challenge remains as to how to disaggregate it and make it accessible to the public.

For Peru, there are further aspects to highlight as positives:

  • It has a relatively strong civil society, actively involved in the tripartite spaces provided by the EITI.
  • There is a decentralised model. The EITI standard is being implemented locally in five regions: Moquegua, Piura, Loreto, Arequipa and Apurímac; and there are plans to begin implementation in three further regions. These include Cuzco and Cajamarca, both of which have a long and difficult history of communities cohabiting with mining.
  • The standard has recognised the importance of transparency in areas other than payments, specifically the social and environmental costs of extractive industries. However, for the standard to continue being relevant, it needs to incorporate data on the impact of extractive industries on climate change and to show what companies are doing to mitigate its effects, beyond just publishing their carbon footprint.

The conference evaluated what needs to happen to strengthen the EITI standard. These are some of the main issues that all panellists agreed upon:

  • Institutionalisation is key, with the need to strengthen public institutions and avert corruption.
  • Decentralisation remains a problem with the need to boost transparency at the local level. Panellists referred to differences in the implementation of the EITI standard locally. It depends on the degree of institutionalisation and the commitment of local authorities. For instance, Piura seems to be the most advanced in this respect, where there is a bureaucratic apparatus that functions relatively independently of local and regional politics.
  • All information, including environmental impacts, needs to be made more accessible. Communities should be able to have easy access and information should be presented in such a way that it is understandable.
  • The EITI standard needs to maintain its relevance by incorporating climate change and mitigation strategies.
  • The impact of extractive industries on women needs to be further incorporated. Gender inclusion has been present in discussions over EITI, but commitments need to be reinforced.
  • The quality of dialogue needs to be improved, with greater articulation between organisations that work on transparency and governance and those in civil society that work on issues of gender, the environment and corruption. The same principle needs to be reflected among government ministries, with more effective linkages established between the Ministry of the Environment (Minam) and the Ministry of Energy and Mines (Minem).

In May this year, Peru was temporarily suspended from the EITI Framework for failing to submit its national transparency report on time. EITI-Peru expressed the hope that this suspension would be lifted by the end of the year.