Peru ratified the ILO Convention 169 on the rights of indigenous peoples 25 years ago, and ten years ago it promulgated the Prior Consultation Law (Law No. 29875) along with its associated regulations. In spite of this, both the legal recognition of prior consultation as a basic right and its implementation in practice are still being contested.
Representatives of the Ministry of Culture and the regional office of the ILO recently met to review what had been achieved. They concluded that 992 agreements had been signed to date. Of the 69 consultations implemented, 30 referred to mining concessions, eleven to oil projects. The state has also issued regulations to promote linguistic diversity and create an indigenous climate change platform. Furthermore, there have been some 30 documents about various aspects of prior consultation, indigenous languages, methodological guides, etc. At the meeting the ILO representative pointed out the need to give greater attention to the quality of consultation.
Despite these achievements, as this newsletter has reported, the Constitutional Tribunal (TC) recently ruled that prior consultation is not a basic right protected by the constitution. This unexpected decision led the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights publicly to express its concern, stating that “the obligation of states to carry out special and differentiated consultation processes when specified interests of indigenous communities and peoples will be affected is nowadays clearly recognised.” The TC’s ruling is currently being appealed.
Meanwhile, on the ground, processes of consultation are still not clear-cut. On 17 March, a meeting of ten of the eleven communities affected by oil Block 200 in the Ucayali and Huánuco regions and their representative organisations – the FECONAU, ORAU and COSHICOX – decided to abandon the consultation process prior to the signing of the exploitation contract between the state company Perupetro and the Spanish oil company CEPSA Perú, the issue being irregularities that were not adequately corrected.
They pointed out that not all the communities affected were invited to take part and that there were not enough translators involved. They expressed their doubt as to the extent to which state authorities were acting in good faith, pointing to the presence of persons who had not been delegated by the communities to represent them. The communities also maintained that they should have been shown the draft version of the contract that Perupetro intended to sign with CEPSA Perú.
Recent Comments