It always seemed likely to fail and it did: far from receiving the support of the 87 members of Congress needed to impeach President Pedro Castillo, only 55 voted in favour whilst 54 members voted against and 19 abstained. So, Castillo continues in office, but with the likelihood of further attempts by the far right to unseat him.

This was the second attempt at impeachment. Last December, however, there were insufficient votes for proceedings even to begin. This time, there was sufficient support in Congress to force Castillo to come before the legislature to respond to a list of 20 alleged misdemeanours. Castillo made a short speech in which he denied the charges made against him, arguing that they were based on rumour, press reports and third-party allegations, not fact.

Responding to the defeat, Jorge Montoya, who had launched the impeachment process, claimed that he would be examining with care the positions of the 19 members who abstained. Of these, 13 belonged to Acción Popular. Those supporting the move came from the three hard right parties that opposed Castilllo’s election last year: Fuerza Popular (the party of unsuccessful candidate Keiko Fujimori), Renovación Popular and Avanza País. Castillo was supported by members belonging to Perú Libre, Juntos por el Perú and Perú Democratico as well as some from other centre-right parties.

As we discussed last week, a number of moves are afoot in Congress to get rid of Castillo, including some involving changes to the constitution. Although the far right may not have sufficient strength for the time being to impeach the president, it controls important commissions in Congress that have the power to carry on harassing the administration and individual ministers. Meanwhile, Congress has continued its practice of censuring ministers, the latest to go being Hernán Condori, the controversial health minister appointed in February.

The pretext for Castillo’s impeachment was that he suffered from “permanent moral incapacity”, a state that the constitution fails to define. The Inter-American Commission of Human Rights issued a statement on 25 March expressing concern for the repeated use of this to undermine the authority of successive Peruvian presidents in ways that “contributed to problems of governability”.