The All-Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) on Peru of the UK Parliament invited the Peru Support Group to organise a joint meeting on Tuesday 22 February on Zoom. The topic was ‘Peru and COP26 commitments – the Challenges Ahead’.
Three speakers joined us from Peru:
Henry Córdova Bran – Coordinator, Citizen Movement against Climate Change (MOCICC)
Osver Polo Carrasco – Climate network officer, Citizen Movement against Climate Change (MOCICC)
Manuel Pulgar-Vidal – Former Environment Minister and Global Leader of Climate and Energy at the World Wildlife Fund for Nature (WWF).
The meeting was chaired by David Mundell, MP, chair of the APPG. Lord Alderdice, the president of the PSG, welcomed the participants and introduced the meeting. Ana Reyes-Hurt, coordinator of the PSG, organised and facilitated the event.
The speakers all felt that COP26 had given Peru appropriate challenges. The problem was the country’s capacity to implement the necessary legislation and change of culture needed to install and sustain healthy policies. Peru, they agreed, is relatively good at introducing individual, well-formulated and appropriate laws. Implementation is another matter. And the speakers stressed the lack of a clear vision and long-term strategy. Also, they added that COP26 itself was not strong on the detail of the required adaptation policies.
Where COP26 was good was on the importance of integrating a wide range of non-state actors into climate change policies. But the challenge of taking such policies from the global to the Peruvian domestic context remains. The institutional base for policy making and implementation is deficient. A key institution in this is the OEFA, the agency within the Ministry of the Environment responsible for oversight and control of the management of the environment. Its powers and resources were reduced under the Humala government (2011-16). The weakness of environmental control has been only too well illustrated by the recent oil spill and its consequences.
Also stressed by all three speakers was the conflict between Peru’s model of extractive-led growth and healthy management of the environment. One described Peru as being in a “gas trap” – the exploitation of rich gas fields hampering a proper transition away from fossil fuels to renewables, meaning that the country was lagging behind its neighbours in this regard. A lead actor needs to be the Ministry of Economy and Finance (MEF). This key institution ought to play a more active role and include the climate criteria in the elaboration of policy across the board. The international community needs to come forward now with financing to back up the policies proposed.
One good institution in Peru is the Commission on Climate Change. This was created in 2020 at the end of the previous government. However, so far, its role has been only consultative, not decision-taking.
A major theme for all speakers was the positive role of indigenous communities in protecting and monitoring environmental effects. This suggests a key issue to develop at COP27 in Egypt, an event very much in the sights of all three speakers.
Another positive point was the potential for the tourism sector to include more educative elements, particularly if tourism is reoriented towards the Amazon. However, the extent of illegal activities limits this, given issues of safety, despite the policy efforts.
MOCICC has prepared a document on institutional deficiencies and needs for environmental policy in Peru, which they are happy to circulate. It details the reasons for its view that, on current evidence, Peru will not meet its target for a 40% reduction in greenhouse gases by 2030.
In discussion the question was raised as to what the UK government could most usefully do to advance these important issues. In reply:
- Manuel Pulgar Vidal focused on the need to offer training to the MEF on the changes needed to bring about the ‘new economy’ required by the climate emergency.
- Osver Polo Carrasco stressed the help needed to achieve the energy transition towards renewables, and the importance of external financing to achieve the country’s just and fair climate plans.
- Henry Córdova reiterated the need to strengthen vigilance and transparency to ensure that policy actually gets through to the communities. He also made the point that the UK should take the lead by cutting its own emissions.
Recent Comments