Peru’s history of mineral ‘resource curses’ looks now to continue with lithium becoming increasingly important in the world economy, and perhaps in Peru’s. Strong development policies to diversify and multiply incomes from natural resources could change the picture but they will require a strong and developmentally focused set of public policies and significant political will.

In Peru, gold, then copper (for which Peru is the second largest world supplier after Chile) and in the 20th century oil and gas were the main extractives. Now lithium can be added to the list since the discovery of lithium hard-rock deposits by Plateau Energy Metals (now owned by American Lithium), associated with their uranium discoveries in Carabaya province, Puno.

The deposit is thought to be the sixth largest rock lithium deposit in the world. The open pit mine is estimated to be able to produce 63,000 tons of lithium carbonate per annum over a mine life of 33 years.

While today world-wide income from lithium is still relatively small it is growing and it has become one of the more important metals needed by modern economies. Currently lithium in batteries cannot be commercially recycled.

Copper remains most important. The output of the ‘old-world’ mineral copper is currently mostly used in construction, such as pipework, and rather less for electrical wiring; in the future the relative importance of electrical and electronic applications will increase.

Lithium production comes from hard-rock mining of minerals and by extraction from brine. Increasingly production will come from hard-rock mining, partly because there are more deposits available and not least because the production from brine involves a very slow process of evaporation. In South America lithium production to date has come mostly from Chile, Bolivia and Argentina, largely using brine extraction methods.

Any mining or production process has technical difficulties that have to be solved, but increasingly the two biggest problems are environmental degradation (including pollution) and effects on the communities around mines and other infrastructures used for ore processing, transport etc. Effects on communities include loss of land, loss of water, migration of people, changes in social structures etc.

Problems of environmental degradation may be assuaged to some extent but effects on communities may not. This may well be just as true for lithium as for copper, gold or other minerals, although in mitigation lithium mines tend to be smaller than those for gold and copper.

Around the world protests over mining and other extractives abound. Over the years, the PSG has documented numerous protests in Peru, but this is a world-wide phenomenon, exemplified by recent protests in Serbia against Rio Tinto’s proposed lithium mine there. So, it may be the case that only those places with relatively dictatorial regimes or sites where populations are small will attract requests for permission to mine. However, low-population areas also often have fragile eco-systems.

Countries like Australia with mine sites in areas of low population density and with a stable government will increasingly attract investment. Currently Australia is the world’s largest lithium producer.

The proposed lithium development in Peru has already attracted controversy.