Notwithstanding the congressional vote of confidence in the cabinet led by Prime Minister Guido Bellido, ministers remain under the threat of censure as opposition leaders seek to attack the administration of President Pedro Castillo. Top of the list is Labour Minister Iber Maraví.

On 27 August, a day later than planned, Congress voted by 73 votes to 50 to approve a vote of confidence in the cabinet, a larger margin than many had expected. The constitution mandates that an incoming cabinet should submit itself to such a vote no more than 30 days after taking office. Castillo announced his cabinet on 29 July, a day after he was sworn in as president.

As we reported, the list of cabinet appointments received widespread criticism, especially in the media and among opposition figures in Congress. Details quickly emerged as to some allegedly dubious antecedents of several members. In mid-August, in advance of the vote of confidence, Foreign Minister Héctor Béjar was forced to resign over comments he was alleged to have made about involvement of naval officials in acts of terrorism in the 1970s and the role played by the CIA.

The criticisms surrounding Maravi centre on the role he is alleged to have played in Sendero Luminoso in the city of Ayacucho at the beginning of the 1980s. As we went to press, his permanence in the cabinet seemed highly doubtful. Maraví, who like Castillo comes from the dissident teachers’ union, denies the veracity of the accusations against him and is prepared to defend himself before Congress.

The margin by which the vote of confidence passed Congress appears to be due, at least in part, to the fact that if Congress refuses a vote of confidence more than once in a five-year presidential term, the president can use this as a pretext to dissolve Congress and call fresh legislative elections. Many members of Congress seem to have believed that refusal of a vote of confidence so early on in an administration would make it easier in the future for Castillo to dismiss them; they preferred to keep their powder dry.

In the event, only the parties on the extreme right – Fuerza Popular, Avanza País and Renovación Popular – insisted on rejecting a vote of confidence. Parties in the centre and centre-right joined with the left-wing Perú Libre and Juntos por el Perú in supporting the Bellido cabinet. They included members from Acción Popular, Alianza para el Progreso, Somos Perú and the Partido Morado.

While the vote of confidence provides Castillo with some breathing space, it represents only a small step towards creating longer-term governability. Opposition leaders, such as Rafael López Aliaga and retired admiral Jorge Montoya (both from Renovación Popular) have been explicit about their plans to censure ministers one by one.

Under the constitution, Congress can call ministers to account (interpelación) and, if dissatisfied with the responses they receive, can force them to resign through motions of censure. A motion of censure must have the backing of at least half the members of Congress. This procedure was used by Fuerza Popular repeatedly after 2016 (when it had a majority of seats in Congress) to threaten and dispense with ministers under the governments of Pedro Pablo Kuczynski and Martín Vizcarra.

In defence of the government, Bellido has threatened to demand further votes of confidence in Congress. To do so would force the Congress to decide whether to allow ministers to stay on or, alternatively, push them into a no-confidence vote which – if repeated – would facilitate dissolution.

The vote of confidence on 27 August followed a lengthy speech by Bellido and a selection of ministers in which they laid out the government’s priorities for the months ahead. By laying emphasis on beefing up the campaign against Covid-19 and restoring levels of employment and wellbeing through economic recovery, Bellido sought to strike a consensual note. The controversial proposal to elect a constituent assembly to rewrite the 1993 constitution received hardly a mention.

Bellido caused a stir when he opened his speech by offering his greetings in Quechua, his language of birth. Members of Congress were swift to shout objections, forcing the president of Congress, Maricarmen Alva, to ask him to speak in Spanish as few in Congress understood Quechua. He replied, also in Quechua, that Article 48 of the constitution made it an official language in Peru, before proceeding in Spanish. In his concluding remarks, Bellido said that he used Quechua “not to upset people” but as a symbolic act of inclusion directed at Peru’s indigenous population and “in homage to the many Peruvians that have died without understanding a word of what is said here”.