Fourteen months after Luis Gonzales Zúñiga was arbitrarily sacked by the then agriculture minister in the Vizcarra government, the courts have ordered the prime minister and new minister of agriculture to re-instate him as executive director of Serfor, the National Forestry and Wildlife Service.

As we reported at the time, in mid-2020 the then minister of agriculture, Jorge Montenegro, asked Gonzales to resign and then fired him when he refused to do so. The minister argued that Gonzales had been appointed to a ‘political’ post (cargo de confianza) and that he retained his position at the minister’s pleasure.

However, Gonzales argued that this was not the case since he had been selected by means of a public and competitive selection and reported to an independent board precisely to ensure his independence from undue political and other pressures.

The board had not been consulted about his dismissal and then voted against it. In doing so, it was supported by a large number of independent human rights and environmental NGOs.

Gonzales had been active in tightening government controls over the export of illegally harvested timber and wildlife. His ouster was publicly supported by the forestry directors in the Madre de Dios, Ucayali and Loreto regions. Subsequently, all three were found to be involved in falsifying logging permits and then charged.

Thus, it was widely believed that Gonzales’s dismissal was due to his ‘inconvenient’ attempts to control illegal activities.

It remains to be seen whether, now that Gonzales has been reinstated, his independence and that of his governing board will be respected and whether he will continue to attempt to control illegal logging and the export of wildlife in the face of the powerful countervailing economic and political interests.