The new administration has gone all out to sell its notion of ‘socially productive investment’ to the mining sector, as we described last week. This can plausibly be seen as a way of making clear the rationale for asking firms to pay more in tax.
In an interview with Reuters on 8 August, Guido Bellido, the new prime minister, also stepped back from earlier statements about state participation. He stressed the need to increase the participation of the state in oil and gas (a statement of much concern to the Camisea consortium) but specified that the mining sector will be left in the control of private enterprise.
However, an increase in taxation will be a crucial part of the policy initiative. Mining is paying already far more in taxation in 2021 than before Covid, but this is due to the rise of international mineral prices.
The administration will be seeking to explore the lifting of the barrier created by ‘tax stability’ agreements. These form part of contracts agreed with individual firms at the outset of a new project that pledge no increase in taxes for the duration of that agreement in return for the payment of 2% extra income tax. The Fujimori administration (1990-2000) used such agreements to attract foreign investment to Peru.
There are still several such agreements in place, albeit fewer than at the peak in the 1990s. Peru has signed as many as 25 such agreements since the 1990s, according to data from the Mines and Energy Ministry (Minem) shared with Reuters. The deals are meant to buffer investors from political or economic upheavals. They cover some of Peru’s largest mining operations:
- Anglo American and partner Mitsubishi signed a deal running up to 2037 for their US$5.3 billion Quellaveco copper mine, soon to be coming on stream.
- MMG, which operates Las Bambas, signed a contract in 2011 that guarantees no change in taxation on its operations until the end of 2030.
- Constancia, operated by Canada’s Hudbay Minerals, has a tax deal which will expire in 2031.
- Cerro Verde, controlled by Freeport McMoRan and Glencore’s Minera Antapaccay both hold similar deals through the end of 2028.
Each of these will run out eventually, but for example in the Quellaveco case not for another 16 years. It is therefore very important to design a new form of contract which does not include such an arrangement.
The most potent obstacle to opposing tax increases is likely to be Congress. Most significant changes in tax regulation either have to go through Congress, or Congress has to agree to delegate the power to decide on that particular change to the executive. As we have seen, Congress, dominated by the right-wing opposition and receptive to private sector lobbying, may well not agree to decisions to raise taxes.
Recent Comments